Review Team

Leave a Reply

132 Comments on "Review Team"

Notify of
avatar
Photo and Image Files
 
 
 
Audio and Video Files
 
 
 
Other File Types
 
 
 
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Joe
Guest

Can you please review the following traders: http://livetraders.com/

They post monthly results on their site. Please review to see if they are fake or legit. Thank you

Don Loiler
Guest
Hi Emmett, I am in a quandary. I am in search of a futures trading room, mentor, and system. I came across your blog and website while researching trading rooms. I have spent over 9 hours reading all your reviews with two or more stars and the comments that followed them. I have got to say that you are a good writer and do a thorough job in your research. I know with all the scum out there pitching their own system you have a lot to write about. I come to realize through your blog and others that I… Read more »
Kevin Davey
Guest
Kevin Davey

Thanks for the nice objective review of my course. I appreciate it. Only one issue – the book you show in the review is not the one I wrote (although I wrote a short chapter for that book by Brent Penfold). My book picture is here: comment image

Thanks again for the review. I think you are providing an important service to the trading community.

arnold
Guest

hi
have you review CRFN new trading sytem called TRADE ALERTS
they say its making more money that the live trading room

Susanne
Guest

Hi Emmett,

I really appreciate your effort – you are definitely providing an important contribution to the trading community.

Here are additional interesting services – your opinion/review would be quite appreciated.

1) marketdelta.com (http://www.marketdelta.com/products/tradingroom)
2) jigsawtrading.com
3) eminivolumetrader.com

Thank you.

ZZZ
Guest

Jigsaw tool is useful. His youtube channel has tons of video that are free, but of course if you don’t buy the software you won’t be able to use it. In essense, he is selling a tool for trading, which I like much better compared to selling a trading room or something.

In addition, I know a live trader who made lots of money using his tool and trading orderflow, he personally met up with Peter the founder. Whether Peter himself is profitable, I cannot attest, but his software is useful indeed.

Not sure about the other stuff

Kevin
Guest

Hi tradingschools.org team, it has been a long time since you’ve updated the website. Are you still working on reviews?

Ryan P.
Guest

Emmett,

First off, thank you very much for all your reviews. They are great! Are you reviewing any rooms right now? Or do you have any plans to review more rooms in the near future?

Thank you
Ryan

Aras
Guest

Hi Emmett,

How are you getting on with a future reviews? I am coming to this site to check over for any news quite often.
It was dead for a couple of months now.
Just give us a small update please !
Thanks ! 🙂

Todd
Guest

Looks like Day Trade Warrior, now called Warrior Trading is having its free chat Monday tomorrow. I only see them do this once a month along with a 7 day trial in the middle of the month or so. Check them out at https://www.warriortrading.com/

Levi Lavel
Guest

Hey Emmett

I appreciate the time you put into helping others, myself included. God bless

CharlesS
Guest
Emmett, Thanks for providing this service to everyone. Any your prose is an unexpected pleasure. I’d suggest a qualifier for your approach: for instructional material. I don’t think it’s so important whether the author trades regularly. Case in point, Steve Primo’s free videos cover several very simple setups that in my multitudinous chart reviews are clearly outstanding. I will be trading them, and do not care whether he does so or not. I agree that his marketing is a bombastic mess of overpriced content, but he’s already given away so much of value for free that I don’t care. I’ve… Read more »
Eddie
Guest

Emmett,
This is a great website with very valuable information. Do you plan on doing a review of chartpattern.com, Dan Zanger’s site? That is a review I would like to see and hopefully soon.
Greatly appreciate your site and the work that you do.
Thanks

Sam
Guest

Hi Emmett,
Great work in reviewing these sites. I really think you are doing a real service to the trading community, since so many sites are set up to take advantage of new or mostly new traders, many of whom do not realize the reality of a successful trader. Have you reviewed “Chartsky Trades”. I asked if he’d give a free trial but he refused. Maybe you’ll have more luck. Thanks again for all your hard work.

Artem
Guest

Hi Emmett,

Also wanted to thanks you for your website. At least you saved a couple of thousand dollars for me that I wanted to invest in Nonko account but changed my mind after reading your post.

I also wanted to ask you if you would be able to look into Colmex broker and especially their educational center and prop-team Tradenet Israel. and their head Meir Barak They are getting very popular with YouRube videos and many people join them, in same time a lot of rumors as a scam are going around.

Your opinion would be very interesting!

Thanks!

Ano
Guest
I have been trading with Colmexpro (Not the prop) They are a bit fishy. Platform looks like Das trader. And every account starts with ‘TR’ DAS clearly states on page 9 in the DAS User Guide (located under the Help Menu on the PRO platform and on our website as of 10/19/12) that “Any account that begins with “TR” is a training account.” Even mr. Meir barak’s account on his youtube videos. Btw. Colmexpro are NOT transparent with fees. You need to ask to see what fees you are paying daily. They are not on ANY blotter in the platform.… Read more »
Ano
Guest

There are not any blotter on the platform, to track broker fees.

By request they send you a excel form with paid broker fees.

Artem
Guest

Ano, as I heard from some traders they take the opposite site (if you trade CFD, and using Colmex you more likely trade CFD). If you become successful, this is no good for them and they would raise fees so you would have to leave them.
More commonly trading CFD you trade air — if you win broker looses, and that is why Colmex is not interested in your success.
At least that is what I know about Colmex. Many familiar trades started with them and left in some months.

Ano
Guest

Yeah. They are taking the opposite position. Many CFD providers does this.

The problem is, Colmex are not transparent with fees. I have daytraded with them for 2 days, and paid over 600 dollars in fees. That came to my knowlegde then i asked for a withdrawel. LOL.

I also believe all the customers are trading on a demo.

Artem
Guest

Yeah, right… Anyway decided to stay away from them. Did not see any real advantages there. Only strong marketing. And a great amount of new traders join watching Meir’s Youtube videos.

Nevertheless should say their Trading room looks really nice (though I visited it 4-5 times only).

Ano
Guest

Tradenets tradingroom should be the real deal. But it can be hard to copy then trading stocks. You need a large account and hard borrows.

kim
Guest
Thank you Emmet for the wonderful hard work you do for the public. You scared me off warrior trading even though I really really wanted to join his chat/classes. Ross Cameron seems so good!!! Anyhow, can you check out “Landshark Analytics”? I’m sure you have a crazy long list of websites to check out but this Dan’s youtube videos are available and I believe there’s a free access to the website for a day or so. I am actually too scared of losing money in regular stocks so I’m looking into options and I came across the website and youtube.… Read more »
RV
Guest

Kim,
Scared money never wins. Do not rush to trade.

-RV

Kaiser Soze
Guest
Kaiser Soze

Wait wait wait. Ross Cameron sounds good but Landshark you want a review on? LOL this has to be Ross or one of his idiot friends after they called you out on StockTwits.

Singh
Guest

I got suckered by them into the mentoring and robot system they have which is not profitable at all. Why would it be with an 8 tick stop loss for 3 tick profit. Out 17 grand 🙁

Singh
Guest

I’m referring to Eminipicks.com

Sad sad lesson for me that will hurt for years to come.

John
Guest

Singh, I’m interested in speaking with you regarding your experience with eminipicks.com. Would you contact me or let me know your email address?

Thanks

Todd
Guest
Hello Emmett. Great stuff here. I have a question for that I will need to preface but I think it is a good question relative to vast majority of rooms refusing too show their DOMs. In inquiring from an outfit called coherentvibrations, that is run by someone in CA and apparently has been started because another outfit was outed as a fraud in Big Mike Trading, called jaguarTrading, this guy is trying to sell is “STUFF” for $80,000!!! yes… I said that. It includes other people’s courses and ‘mentorship’ and training and a HUGE committment to your ‘guaranteed success’ blah… Read more »
Richard
Guest

Hey Emmet

Straight up, i want to learn how to swing trade, what educational service do you recommend me?

Also, Awesome website man! congratulations keep up the good work!!!

Richard

Eric
Guest

Thank you.. This is great stuff! I have read almost everything on your site. Have you done a review of eminitutor.com? I think the guys name is Horst. He posts youtube videos almost daily of his trades. I don’t think he has a trade room. He does tutoring sessions over a few months. I think he charges 4-5k. I would be very interested know if his trades are real live money trades or completely fabricated.
Thanks

Keep up the good work!

Christian
Guest

Hi Emmett,
Since it’s been a while since you did not review a good futures trading room let me suggest one:openrangetrading.com

Tom
Guest

Emmett,
How about Rob Mitchell’s 4-5 sites that all refer back to an indicator sales site.
A simple Google Search and 4-5 of his sites come up and they all refer to :
http://indicatorsmart.com/product/smart-patterns-ultimate-otr

Guy seems like an indicator hawk.

robert frank
Guest
robert frank

have you ever reviewed netpicks

sam
Guest
netpicks is a total scam. I know myself and one other guy who lost money trying to trade their calls. And they have the gall to show backtest results complaining if people stuck around all year. It’s the usual monthly churn rate. People leave after a month or two after perpetual losers and realize they’ve been had. And new people come in to be duped. The same shill actors who are probably the hosts themselves are in the room who beat you up if you complain. They have tried to re-invent themselves multiple times among various websites and variations of… Read more »
robert frank
Guest
robert frank

emmett have you ever looked at a prop firm called apiary funds its forex. Thanks for the good work you do.

ElaineMDG
Guest
There’s a BUNCH of both positive AND negative on Apiary over at ForexPeaceArmy. (Including posts by the CEO) Lower priced “education fee”, but seemingly above-board Prop firm Blue-Point Trading has caught my interest. But I want to make sure I save a “cushion” before I go any further-so I can fall back on just retail trading if it doesn’t work out. They have some good, FREE educational material available and the traders I’ve spoken to there, as well as several conversations with the CEO, William Thompson (Blue); have come across as open and honest. But, that’s just my own humble… Read more »
simon culley
Guest

Hi
after reading your article on finding the right mentor ,I came across naed Nial Fuller.He claims to trade Himself.Other people seem to think not.I asked Him why,if he does trade,why does nt he post live trades.The reason he said was for legal issues.Do you know of Him and if this would be true?

many thanks
Simon.

sam
Guest

Right , they all claim to trade themselves, even those price action “teachers” like Lance Beggs of YTD and price action by Mac where they just keep drawing circles on after the fact charts on youtube or newsletters. Never any stats, proof or records, just lousy spam email or youtube “journals”.

Rob B
Member

I am amazed how many people follow Mack and his hindsight mark up of charts. Once I would like him to try and calls a trade live. The funny thing is when I use to look at his charts in the old days I always found 5 other trades that also could be circled that were losers that somehow he never circled or would explain. He is a complete joke.

And for Beggs, I still gets his emails of hindsight chart analysis. Again never any proof any of these guys trade profitably.

JT
Guest

Hello Here is a video recording of MOJO DAYTRADING that is worth watching. Would like to hear your take on it especially how he cost average down on stocks such as PSDV https://youtu.be/Jdinx5n9Kd8

JT
Guest

Hello Emmett, Would be nice if you could do a review on Ken Calhoun at tradingtheopen.com

Francis
Guest
Calhoun is a great guy and I have met him personally thanks to one of his seminars going back 11 years now. It was internet marketing related, not trading related. Lots of respect that I have for Ken as his a straight up honest guy and well intention guy based on my own deductions/conclusions from the advice he personally gave me back then in the seminar and the image he had going back to 2005 with Corey Rudl, J., Reese and a bunch of other online marketing gurus. Would be interesting(and I’ll either love or dislike Emmett perhaps a little)… Read more »
Bill
Guest

Just wanted to thank you for giving us this forum to expose the frauds.

I have been using your threads alot lately and cant thank you enough for having this available.

Mitchell
Guest

Emmitt, Thank you for this site. I am wanting to find a good honest course and almost got involved in one that it seems is NOT that.

You mentioned, in response to someone else, that they could email you with their budget etc.

I cannot seem to find your email to ask you a few questions. Can I possible get it?

Thanks
Mitch

Mitchell
Guest

Opps…. Emmett 🙂

Joe
Guest

What is consensus here? If vendor sells indicators and mentorships then run for the hills?

Jerry pane
Guest
sam
Guest

I guess it depends on what you want from reviews. An actor with a crime scene voice like Stacy Keach of American Greed who reads scripts and personally doesn’t know much about the trading business. Or someone who’s been there in the depths , has served his time to society and is turning a new leaf doing real reviews on the trading scam industry.

PTA
Guest

Any thoughts on Premier Trading Solutions, a “pie in the sky” institutional order flow educator and hedge fund creator?

janice
Guest

Hi Emmett is there a day trading room that you recommend that trades stocks only. You have some good reviews on forex and options. I was considering Daytradingpower then read your latest review. Seems like everyone is teaching but I cannot one that practices what they preach.

Thanks

Ed Wilson
Guest

Emmett
In your opinion is it possible to make money day trading with any level of consistency?

Thanks

Ed

Allen
Guest

Could you please review Chuck Hughes? What he writes seems correct but what is shown as examples is mostly old stuff from 2005. Plus he has won the World Cup Championship (http://www.worldcupchampionships.com/live-stats-3) 8 times, but mostly Stocks and Futures, but this may be that they don’t monitor/award for options. What he is pushing is options, through various places, one is Hughes Optionengineering.

John
Guest

Can you recommend a school or mentor for trading the ES? I like scalping for a point but also like shooting for 2-4 point targets as well. I’ve tried several mentors but I have not found a method I can trade. It’s seems these mentors are either using lagging indicators or as with trading price action if you don’t have your trend and channel lines drawn exactly right, the market just chews you up. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

Patrick
Guest

Any thought on reviewing https://www.sanglucci.com/ ? And the “Sang Lucci” Method?

sam
Guest
This is a strange site. Their staff roster is big which looks more like a software development company team. Two hedge funds are mentioned, “Sang Lucci Capital Partners, LP”, and “Flammarion Capital Partners, LP”. Is there a way to check how these hedge funds performed, RobB? Then one of the members is/was? a HFT trader for Flammarion. http://www.benzinga.com/markets/futures/14/11/4954773/a-day-in-the-life-of-a-high-frequency-trader correct me if I”m wrong, but I thought it was the other way where trading education vendors strive to be profitable enough to become hedge funds rather than the other way around. Otherwise it looks like the typical 225/month room and $400/$255… Read more »
Rob B
Guest

A lot of times I think these people are just pooled money and not even a legit hedge fund. More than likely at best this is some dinky very small hedge fund, where you might have to ask them to show proof of performance. You can start by searching the SEC

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1544226/000154422614000003/0001544226-14-000003-index.htm

sam
Guest

Thanks RobB. The address seems to be part of this office space for startups, https://www.wework.com/locations/new-york-city/nomad ; Nothing on CNBC about Lucci captial or Flammarion except Flammarion was referred to on zerohedge: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-05-29/generation-rate-hike-rookies-makes-jeff-gundlach-nervous, as a bunch of young guys watching hft algos; well I guess I could conclude like you said, small pools which hasn’t really taken off, so they chose to do “trading education” on the side ultimately becoming another vendor group. Maybe they ought to “scale down expenses” and move to the countryside farm house like Ross said he did, lol.

Morton Levin
Guest

any traders familiar with Advanced commodity trading software

David
Guest

What about Trading Futures in Action, with Sandy Sehgal and Bob Amico? I recall that you were planning to review them around February or March 2016 but I have not yet seen the review. They post some impressive results and claim to be doing all trades with the DOM visible.

Guest
Guest
David, what I have seen in the room seems to be good. Here are some issues, Dr dean is in the room. And he is also in the room trade for greatness. And, he owns the trade room tradeforgreatness from April for when I reached out to April asking her that the the gains posted are amazing and if she had any proff to back those gains, and reply came back from Dr Dean. Bob Amico was charged with fraud for real estate: http://newyork.realestaterama.com/2007/11/01/amicos-plead-guilty-in-connection-with-60-million-mortgage-fraud-conspiracy-case-ID0112.html. The room just opened. If someone shows their DOM does not mean they are trading live,… Read more »
ZZZ
Guest
Hi Emmett, your site is great. It’s awesome to see you have gone great length to reveal these scans. I have purchased a subscription from Tim Sykes in 2011 when I first started trading. Also paid another guru in the past. It’s all tuition now that I think of it. Can you take a look at Wall Street Jesus, and some of the option rooms, as well as Triforce trading, which is affiliated with Profit.ly. I know they are businesses, but would like to see your take as I have some friends who are asking me if they should pay… Read more »
Patrick Michael
Guest

Any reviews on Academy Day Trading? Also Viper Trading Systems? Thank you

Pat

Keith
Guest

Where is the review gone of picksthatmakecents.com? or tradewithkavan.com?
Emmett got paid huh ?

Anonymous
Guest

Hello, Could you do a review on Charlie Burton’s Ezeetrader room and Jerremy Newsome’s RealLifeTrading?

Charlie seems to be very consistent and has been featured on a BBC Trader documentary. He always talks about risk mitigation, which seems to be a sign that he is the real deal. However, I think one cannot join his day trading room unless his course is purchased.

Thank you

Tom
Guest

Hello, I came across your website and looking for some reputable stock swing trade services offering entry and exit points.Thanks in advance Tom

Tom
Guest

Hello doing a test to see if this posts,please reply back.Thanks

Tom
Guest

Hello,Emmett can you give me a few recommendations for a swing trade site with entry and exit points.I just tried a trial with jasonbondpicks.com.Thanks Tom

Rob B
Guest
Tom, First I will give you credit not looking for one of these Day Trading Sites, but the odds of you following someone else entry and exit and being profitable IMO is about zero. What happens when they have a 30% pullback will you panic sell everything? You need to know why you entered into a position and know when you will exit. I have yet to meet anyone making money following someone else calls over the long term. If you are going to do that I would suggest you be better off dollar cost averaging into the several mutual… Read more »
rtchoke
Guest
“You need to know why you entered into a position and know when you will exit.” (from Rob B). Correct. Yep. There are two things you might want if you are a new trader. The first is you want to learn how to trade, so the moderator of the room should be showing you “if A and B, then C” giving you a clear cut picture of what is happening to get ready to trade. Then he should give you stop loss and targets (before or as he enters the trade). And he should stick to those stop loss numbers.… Read more »
Tom
Guest

Hello all

Stray Dog
Guest

Hello Tom, On the right side of the homepage are two headings; “Best Trading Systems” and “Highly Ranked Trading Rooms.” The Highly Ranked Trading Rooms are probably what you are looking for.

JohnA
Guest

Hi Emmet,

I read your article on Glenridge Capital. I wish I had seen your article before I started an account with them. Their head analyst is called Ryan Daniels. Is that his real name? Is he also located in Tel Aviv? Where is their Tel Aviv office?

Thanks .. John

John
Guest

Hi Kevin,

I wish I had read your article on Glenridge Capital before I started an account there. Do you know where in Israel their office is? Do you know their Head Analyst Ryan Daniels?

Thanks ..J

Don
Guest
Hi Emmett, I am in a quandary. I am in search of a futures trading room, mentor, and system. I came across your blog and website while researching trading rooms. I have spent over 9 hours reading all your reviews with two or more stars and the comments that followed them. I have got to say that you are a good writer and do a thorough job in your research. I know with all the scum out there pitching their own system you have a lot to write about. I come to realize through your blog and others that I… Read more »
Alex
Guest

Hey Emmett,

So where is an update review on TradewithKavan ?

John Dakota
Guest

What are your thoughts on academydaytrading.com and their pro9 software?

wpDiscuz