Home / Review Team Review Team Comments (130) Kevin Davey January 7, 2015 Thanks for the nice objective review of my course. I appreciate it. Only one issue – the book you show in the review is not the one I wrote (although I wrote a short chapter for that book by Brent Penfold). My book picture is here: http://www.kjtradingsystems.com/uploads/2/7/2/8/2728902/_9397680.jpg Thanks again for the review. I think you are providing an important service to the trading community. Reply Emmett Moore January 9, 2015 Hi Kevin, Thanks for leaving a comment. Will get that book cover updated now. And link it out to your page. I am not doing much for the community. You are the one doing something for the trading community. I just want to help you get your message above the noisy clutter and chicanery. -Emmett Reply Russ February 12, 2015 Emmet, You are as humble as you are helpful. You are likely saving people thousands of dollars. Not only that you are putting in countless hours and spending your own money to hire people to assist you in your quest. Please accept a well deserved pat on the back. Im sure there are many silent reviewers that feel the same, On with the good work. ps: You really should put up a donations link to help offset some of the costs, -RV Reply Emmett Moore February 12, 2015 Hi RV, Thanks for the kind note. Seriously, its what keeps me moving forward. Currently the site is monetized with Google Adsense, which is currently generating about a dollar a day. After I get 400 reviews up, the site should generate enough to pay staff to continue to monitor. The grunt work is off shored in the Phillipines to keep costs at a minimum. The final result should be a self sufficient site where ad revenue is pooled and anyone that wants to write reviews, can serve a dual function of writing performance reviews and earning money by trading the best performing services. This system is working pretty well with my teenager, he trades a small account and gets to keep whatever is earned by matching the trades as per the room moderator. In exchange, he does the grunt work of time stamping the video and writing a summary than can be used for further reviews. Emmett Reply Francis January 24, 2016 I am sure that $1 a day average is because of where the ads are being placed and the focus of the overall sites which is reviewing trade material. Fast forward a year from now and I bet adsense is at the very least $5 a day with the horrible ad placements. Either way who cares as the focus shouldn’t be Adsense now and it should still be reviews, secondary advertising space I will guess for this niche. I know adding a “donate” button would put a halt in my own ego as a business man, but this will actually bee seen even on a better light on my end as there’s just an extreme amount of well done reviews that deserve greater amount of respect then just Adsense. I’m sure the 6 figure earners that are carefully reading this website will surely add to $100’s a month thanks to “donate” buttons. Hope you reconsider Emmett as I’ll surely donate out of respect for the well deserved B12 and WatchHimTrade reviews you did alone. Reply Allen Schaaf February 15, 2016 Yep, a donate button would have gotten $100 today, the first day I have seen this site! Emmett, if you contact me directly at my e-mail address I will send you a check. Reply Gig Hilton October 2, 2015 Emmett, I was asked to read your post regarding Back to the Future Trading, and perhaps reply. I read the entire post, quite long and detailed for sure. Here are my thoughts: My experience with BTTF has been about 3 years. I was introduced to them at the Advance Trading Workshop run by Jerry Simmons. I think your point that the software “doesn’t work” because Michael won’t trade it live in the room… is on its face lacking of understanding. Michael and Ron are not CTA’s and cannot legally give trading advice. What they can do, is show you how their software works and how it can be used in trading. And if you listen carefully in the room, they are trading it! Just not giving advice. There are three to five basic trade setups that work like clockwork, but you have to learn to see the setup and learn how to trade it, just like anything else that isn’t’ black box! The premise that the software predicts buys and sells is incorrect. I don’t know anyone that just buys when the software says buy and sells when it says sell. That is not the way to use this software. It is a timing mechanism! The basis of the software is data mining under the premise that history repeats itself. But to think that “it doesn’t work” because buying and selling dots sometimes don’t match up, is wrong and too simplistic reasoning. The Flux is a timing tool, and I have found a great guide to “WHEN” to engage the market. There is price, time, and volume…. When they line up, you have the best of the best trades! But to trade it like you claimed in your post by just taking trade dots, is grossly incorrect! For example…. BTTF suggests that the timing is 60 to 70% accurate. I am sure that is about right on its face…. But not a great edge unless you have money management and a trade plan of limited stops and profit targets. However, if you take and look at the length of a cycle, the Power Zone, and then look at taking only the AMACD ( short term cycles) in the direction of the trend, I think the percentage of accurate timing turns increases to 80 to 90%. That is my experience. And in addition, I have found certain price formations occur with a timing turn, that is 95% accurate … in the opposite direction… Yes, this seems counter intuitive, but it is…like two negatives make a positive. For example, if you get a lower low, and a red sell timing dot occurs on that bar, it is a great place to buy. The market is exhausted. So to summarize my point, consider how to use this timing tool before you say that the owner doesn’t trade it, and that it doesn’t work and is fool’s gold. IT has not been fool’s gold to me. I can look at the histograms and know when I want to consider trading. You do have to learn how to interpret what you are seeing…and that isn’t a bad thing! I won’t take a trade without it! And I know quite a few others who feel the same way, yet trade completely differently than I do. If you have any questions or would like to know more, feel free to contact me. Respectfully, Gig Hilton Lexington, N.C. 27292 336-596-0446 Reply Emmett Moore October 2, 2015 Hey Gig, As you can see, I took the review down. I am looking for one of two things: either customers that have successfully used the software to turn a profit, or the presence of a trading DOM during the live trading sessions. There are a lot of folks on the internet selling all sorts of trading indicators, I am just writing a review, its an opinion piece. My opinion is certainly not the gospel. And BackToTheFutureTrading is certainly not anywhere near the worst vendors in this space. Yes, my reviews are tough for the vendor to read, but its intentional and its meant to drive transparency and proof of concept. Surely you can agree that this industry needs more transparency. Respectfully, Emmett Reply Stray Dog October 2, 2015 Sounds like a idea that has some similarities to Robert C. Miner’s “High Probability Trading Strategies.” He uses a dual time frame momentum indicator that can be replicated on the thinkorswim platform using the StocRSI and adjusting it to match the numbers on page 38 of Miner’s book. RSI length = 21 OB = 75 OS = 25 RSI choice = close k period = 13 d period = 8 slow period = 8 smoothing type = ema Reply Jamil January 17, 2016 Hi Emmet, Can you do a review on Meir Barak? Thanks in advance. Reply arnold January 9, 2015 hi have you review CRFN new trading sytem called TRADE ALERTS they say its making more money that the live trading room Reply Susanne March 1, 2015 Hi Emmett, I really appreciate your effort – you are definitely providing an important contribution to the trading community. Here are additional interesting services – your opinion/review would be quite appreciated. 1) marketdelta.com (http://www.marketdelta.com/products/tradingroom) 2) jigsawtrading.com 3) eminivolumetrader.com Thank you. Reply Emmett Moore March 1, 2015 Hi Susanne, Am currently vetting Anthony Drager at the Market Delta trading room. Thanks for the taking the time to write. Jigsaw and eminivolume on are the list. Emmett Reply ZZZ June 28, 2016 Jigsaw tool is useful. His youtube channel has tons of video that are free, but of course if you don’t buy the software you won’t be able to use it. In essense, he is selling a tool for trading, which I like much better compared to selling a trading room or something. In addition, I know a live trader who made lots of money using his tool and trading orderflow, he personally met up with Peter the founder. Whether Peter himself is profitable, I cannot attest, but his software is useful indeed. Not sure about the other stuff Reply Kevin March 19, 2015 Hi tradingschools.org team, it has been a long time since you’ve updated the website. Are you still working on reviews? Reply Ryan P. April 5, 2015 Emmett, First off, thank you very much for all your reviews. They are great! Are you reviewing any rooms right now? Or do you have any plans to review more rooms in the near future? Thank you Ryan Reply Aras April 11, 2015 Hi Emmett, How are you getting on with a future reviews? I am coming to this site to check over for any news quite often. It was dead for a couple of months now. Just give us a small update please ! Thanks ! 🙂 Reply Todd May 4, 2015 Looks like Day Trade Warrior, now called Warrior Trading is having its free chat Monday tomorrow. I only see them do this once a month along with a 7 day trial in the middle of the month or so. Check them out at https://www.warriortrading.com/ Reply Levi Lavel May 30, 2015 Hey Emmett I appreciate the time you put into helping others, myself included. God bless Reply CharlesS June 28, 2015 Emmett, Thanks for providing this service to everyone. Any your prose is an unexpected pleasure. I’d suggest a qualifier for your approach: for instructional material. I don’t think it’s so important whether the author trades regularly. Case in point, Steve Primo’s free videos cover several very simple setups that in my multitudinous chart reviews are clearly outstanding. I will be trading them, and do not care whether he does so or not. I agree that his marketing is a bombastic mess of overpriced content, but he’s already given away so much of value for free that I don’t care. I’ve also looked carefully at the signals that his heavily-marketed and proprietary ‘PET-D’ gives and have determined that he’s using a variation of a long-standing technique — one less reason to buy his content. If a novice does not have this perspective, he/she will likely still benefit from Primo’s commercial content, if they follow it. What matters with instructional material here is the potential profitability of the content — does it matter to the credibility of F=MA that Newton did not build bridges ? Where I would be concerned about whether a ‘master trader’ actually trades is if he/she offers a recommendation service, or runs a chat room where you’re supposed to learn how to trade in real time. This is a completely different kind of service than course content. This is where a long-term record is essential, where I think your approach is spot-on. In the case of recommendations, I also think it’s more complicated, if the service is trying to teach you to trade, rather than just give you orders to follow. Deciding on a trade’s goal and management is very specific to each trader’s psychology. Every setup, once live in the market, can be managed profitably in many ways, and the role of the ‘master trader’ in my view is to help you arrive at profitable way(s) that you specifically can run the trade. In this case, I think the more meaningful approach is to ask the ‘master trader’ to publish the recommendations and dates of recommendations, not necessarily all the other details, unless the service is understood strictly as a non-instructional trade recommendation service. Again, thanks for your great service, I’ll be returning regularly. Best, CharlesS Reply Eddie July 23, 2015 Emmett, This is a great website with very valuable information. Do you plan on doing a review of chartpattern.com, Dan Zanger’s site? That is a review I would like to see and hopefully soon. Greatly appreciate your site and the work that you do. Thanks Reply Sam July 23, 2015 Hi Emmett, Great work in reviewing these sites. I really think you are doing a real service to the trading community, since so many sites are set up to take advantage of new or mostly new traders, many of whom do not realize the reality of a successful trader. Have you reviewed “Chartsky Trades”. I asked if he’d give a free trial but he refused. Maybe you’ll have more luck. Thanks again for all your hard work. Reply Emmett Moore July 23, 2015 Chartsky. Got it. Reply Artem July 28, 2015 Hi Emmett, Also wanted to thanks you for your website. At least you saved a couple of thousand dollars for me that I wanted to invest in Nonko account but changed my mind after reading your post. I also wanted to ask you if you would be able to look into Colmex broker and especially their educational center and prop-team Tradenet Israel. and their head Meir Barak They are getting very popular with YouRube videos and many people join them, in same time a lot of rumors as a scam are going around. Your opinion would be very interesting! Thanks! Reply Emmett Moore July 28, 2015 Yes, have gotten several requests. Am on it! Reply murali February 12, 2016 Hi Emmett, are you trying to get review on tradenet any soon ? Reply Ano July 28, 2015 I have been trading with Colmexpro (Not the prop) They are a bit fishy. Platform looks like Das trader. And every account starts with ‘TR’ DAS clearly states on page 9 in the DAS User Guide (located under the Help Menu on the PRO platform and on our website as of 10/19/12) that “Any account that begins with “TR” is a training account.” Even mr. Meir barak’s account on his youtube videos. Btw. Colmexpro are NOT transparent with fees. You need to ask to see what fees you are paying daily. They are not on ANY blotter in the platform. And the fees are filled in a very fishy excel form. Reply Ano July 28, 2015 There are not any blotter on the platform, to track broker fees. By request they send you a excel form with paid broker fees. Reply Artem July 29, 2015 Ano, as I heard from some traders they take the opposite site (if you trade CFD, and using Colmex you more likely trade CFD). If you become successful, this is no good for them and they would raise fees so you would have to leave them. More commonly trading CFD you trade air — if you win broker looses, and that is why Colmex is not interested in your success. At least that is what I know about Colmex. Many familiar trades started with them and left in some months. Reply Ano July 29, 2015 Yeah. They are taking the opposite position. Many CFD providers does this. The problem is, Colmex are not transparent with fees. I have daytraded with them for 2 days, and paid over 600 dollars in fees. That came to my knowlegde then i asked for a withdrawel. LOL. I also believe all the customers are trading on a demo. Reply Artem July 29, 2015 Yeah, right… Anyway decided to stay away from them. Did not see any real advantages there. Only strong marketing. And a great amount of new traders join watching Meir’s Youtube videos. Nevertheless should say their Trading room looks really nice (though I visited it 4-5 times only). Reply Ano July 30, 2015 Tradenets tradingroom should be the real deal. But it can be hard to copy then trading stocks. You need a large account and hard borrows. Reply kim September 1, 2015 Thank you Emmet for the wonderful hard work you do for the public. You scared me off warrior trading even though I really really wanted to join his chat/classes. Ross Cameron seems so good!!! Anyhow, can you check out “Landshark Analytics”? I’m sure you have a crazy long list of websites to check out but this Dan’s youtube videos are available and I believe there’s a free access to the website for a day or so. I am actually too scared of losing money in regular stocks so I’m looking into options and I came across the website and youtube. Landscape strictly recommends buying puts/calls as opposed to http://www.optionsellers.com/ where the latter only advocates selling of the option premiums. What is your advice on this? I am just so lost…I need a better guide!! Thank you!!! Reply RV September 2, 2015 Kim, Scared money never wins. Do not rush to trade. -RV Reply Kaiser Soze September 16, 2015 Wait wait wait. Ross Cameron sounds good but Landshark you want a review on? LOL this has to be Ross or one of his idiot friends after they called you out on StockTwits. Reply Singh September 10, 2015 I got suckered by them into the mentoring and robot system they have which is not profitable at all. Why would it be with an 8 tick stop loss for 3 tick profit. Out 17 grand 🙁 Reply Singh September 10, 2015 I’m referring to Eminipicks.com Sad sad lesson for me that will hurt for years to come. Reply John December 7, 2015 Singh, I’m interested in speaking with you regarding your experience with eminipicks.com. Would you contact me or let me know your email address? Thanks Reply Todd September 19, 2015 Hello Emmett. Great stuff here. I have a question for that I will need to preface but I think it is a good question relative to vast majority of rooms refusing too show their DOMs. In inquiring from an outfit called coherentvibrations, that is run by someone in CA and apparently has been started because another outfit was outed as a fraud in Big Mike Trading, called jaguarTrading, this guy is trying to sell is “STUFF” for $80,000!!! yes… I said that. It includes other people’s courses and ‘mentorship’ and training and a HUGE committment to your ‘guaranteed success’ blah blah blah…. and includes the guy’s stuff who was outed as a fraud. He is a part of this new room etc… Anyway, when I inquired about showing his dome… This is the dribble I got… The FTC, and CFTC, the government agency that regulates trading has already given me a phone call questioning me about providing investment advice, this is something I cannot do. Therefore I have been instructed that I may only provide hypothetical trading opportunities. What this means is that I cannot show my dome …. I can show it in Sim, but I cannot show it live because that would be providing specific investment advice and anybody that does that is setting themselves up sooner or later for a very big fine. Of course, he does not even show it in SIM. Any truth to any of this that he says, and I expect others do as well?? Thanks Emmett Reply Emmett Moore September 20, 2015 Anyone that tells you that they cannot show performance…has performance issues. Dont believe the rest of the nonsense. Reply Richard September 21, 2015 Hey Emmet Straight up, i want to learn how to swing trade, what educational service do you recommend me? Also, Awesome website man! congratulations keep up the good work!!! Richard Reply Emmett Moore September 21, 2015 I like B12 Trader. I wrote a review. Swing trading, very good service. Honest. Reply Stray Dog September 21, 2015 And here’s a free site with some useful information: all the Ws swing-trade-stocks dot com/ Reply Eric November 30, 2015 Thank you.. This is great stuff! I have read almost everything on your site. Have you done a review of eminitutor.com? I think the guys name is Horst. He posts youtube videos almost daily of his trades. I don’t think he has a trade room. He does tutoring sessions over a few months. I think he charges 4-5k. I would be very interested know if his trades are real live money trades or completely fabricated. Thanks Keep up the good work! Reply Christian December 5, 2015 Hi Emmett, Since it’s been a while since you did not review a good futures trading room let me suggest one:openrangetrading.com Reply Tom December 11, 2015 Emmett, How about Rob Mitchell’s 4-5 sites that all refer back to an indicator sales site. A simple Google Search and 4-5 of his sites come up and they all refer to : http://indicatorsmart.com/product/smart-patterns-ultimate-otr Guy seems like an indicator hawk. Reply robert frank December 12, 2015 have you ever reviewed netpicks Reply sam May 28, 2016 netpicks is a total scam. I know myself and one other guy who lost money trying to trade their calls. And they have the gall to show backtest results complaining if people stuck around all year. It’s the usual monthly churn rate. People leave after a month or two after perpetual losers and realize they’ve been had. And new people come in to be duped. The same shill actors who are probably the hosts themselves are in the room who beat you up if you complain. They have tried to re-invent themselves multiple times among various websites and variations of their same lousy software. Seven Summits, keltner bells, puAcademy whatever scammy nonsense. Seriously Emmett you need to do an expose review on them since they are a legacy sham and one of the most visible snakeoil wagontrains on the web. They’re scammy influence is longer and bigger than nexgen and most other futures trading scamuvendors. Reply robert frank December 14, 2015 emmett have you ever looked at a prop firm called apiary funds its forex. Thanks for the good work you do. Reply ElaineMDG March 28, 2016 There’s a BUNCH of both positive AND negative on Apiary over at ForexPeaceArmy. (Including posts by the CEO) Lower priced “education fee”, but seemingly above-board Prop firm Blue-Point Trading has caught my interest. But I want to make sure I save a “cushion” before I go any further-so I can fall back on just retail trading if it doesn’t work out. They have some good, FREE educational material available and the traders I’ve spoken to there, as well as several conversations with the CEO, William Thompson (Blue); have come across as open and honest. But, that’s just my own humble opinion. Good Luck! Reply simon culley December 21, 2015 Hi after reading your article on finding the right mentor ,I came across naed Nial Fuller.He claims to trade Himself.Other people seem to think not.I asked Him why,if he does trade,why does nt he post live trades.The reason he said was for legal issues.Do you know of Him and if this would be true? many thanks Simon. Reply Emmett Moore December 21, 2015 Nial is a phony. I wrote a review about him. Anyone that tell you that he cannot disclose for legal reasons is trying to steal your money. Reply ElaineMDG March 28, 2016 Oops!! Perhaps my judgement isn’t so hot after all! I’ve exchanged 3-4 emails with this kid and his trades appeared valid-but will certainly read review. Not sure how I missed it!! I was referred to Nial by a trader at FXStreet after I expressed my desire to learn more about Price Action. My comment I sent you was only based on the past week or so of speaking to him. I think he was recommended because Ben’s prices for his online course & seminars are WAY over my limit! (And HIS trades ARE 3rd party verified!) Reply Stray Dog March 29, 2016 @ElaineMDG therre’s more than enough education to keep you busy for a month or more at babypips dot com/school Reply sam March 29, 2016 Right , they all claim to trade themselves, even those price action “teachers” like Lance Beggs of YTD and price action by Mac where they just keep drawing circles on after the fact charts on youtube or newsletters. Never any stats, proof or records, just lousy spam email or youtube “journals”. Reply Rob B March 29, 2016 I am amazed how many people follow Mack and his hindsight mark up of charts. Once I would like him to try and calls a trade live. The funny thing is when I use to look at his charts in the old days I always found 5 other trades that also could be circled that were losers that somehow he never circled or would explain. He is a complete joke. And for Beggs, I still gets his emails of hindsight chart analysis. Again never any proof any of these guys trade profitably. Reply JT December 23, 2015 Hello Here is a video recording of MOJO DAYTRADING that is worth watching. Would like to hear your take on it especially how he cost average down on stocks such as PSDV https://youtu.be/Jdinx5n9Kd8 Reply JT December 31, 2015 Hello Emmett, Would be nice if you could do a review on Ken Calhoun at tradingtheopen.com Reply Francis January 24, 2016 Calhoun is a great guy and I have met him personally thanks to one of his seminars going back 11 years now. It was internet marketing related, not trading related. Lots of respect that I have for Ken as his a straight up honest guy and well intention guy based on my own deductions/conclusions from the advice he personally gave me back then in the seminar and the image he had going back to 2005 with Corey Rudl, J., Reese and a bunch of other online marketing gurus. Would be interesting(and I’ll either love or dislike Emmett perhaps a little) if Emmett decides to pull a review on him as I know Ken has been teaching day trading for many years now and Emmett doesn’t sugarcoat in his line of biz (neither do I) JT, do know that Ken is a master copywriter and excellent salesman with lots of video technical know how as he has been online for over 20+ years doing business online. Very intelligent and honest guy in my personal view because of experiences in his previous internet marketing teachings. I definitely vouch for Calhoun, JT. If he offers a money back guarantee I know he’ll honor it, that’s a surefire backup on your end just in case he offers a guarantee of money back. And if you check my sig my attached site you’ll confirm I also have a keen interest in trading and finding the very best choice for learning trade, so we’re in the same boat and it obviously isn’t a fan or a paid review. Thanks for reminding me about Ken, you just reminded me about him and I actually can’t believe I forgot about him for learning trade as what I learned from then back 10+ years ago wasn’t “day trading” specifically back then, so amused by it in a way! Thanks for the comment in a way. Reply Bill January 3, 2016 Just wanted to thank you for giving us this forum to expose the frauds. I have been using your threads alot lately and cant thank you enough for having this available. Reply Mitchell January 4, 2016 Emmitt, Thank you for this site. I am wanting to find a good honest course and almost got involved in one that it seems is NOT that. You mentioned, in response to someone else, that they could email you with their budget etc. I cannot seem to find your email to ask you a few questions. Can I possible get it? Thanks Mitch Reply Mitchell January 4, 2016 Opps…. Emmett 🙂 Reply Joe January 28, 2016 What is consensus here? If vendor sells indicators and mentorships then run for the hills? Reply Jerry pane February 12, 2016 http://tradingschools.info/2015/08/05/a-review-of-emmett-moore/ Please explain this Reply Emmett Moore February 12, 2016 I think its pretty self explanatory! Lol. Reply sam May 28, 2016 I guess it depends on what you want from reviews. An actor with a crime scene voice like Stacy Keach of American Greed who reads scripts and personally doesn’t know much about the trading business. Or someone who’s been there in the depths , has served his time to society and is turning a new leaf doing real reviews on the trading scam industry. Reply PTA April 10, 2016 Any thoughts on Premier Trading Solutions, a “pie in the sky” institutional order flow educator and hedge fund creator? Reply janice April 13, 2016 Hi Emmett is there a day trading room that you recommend that trades stocks only. You have some good reviews on forex and options. I was considering Daytradingpower then read your latest review. Seems like everyone is teaching but I cannot one that practices what they preach. Thanks Reply Emmett Moore April 13, 2016 For day trading stocks, I like WatchHimTrade.com. You are getting a guy that actually does trade. For day trading futures I like Alex Soares at TradingPriceActionOnFutures.com. Actually, there a few guys that I like for futures. Jason at The Oil Trading Group is a really nice guy, but you need a larger account. I also like old Dave at Learn To Trade and Invest. Dave and I have a had an interesting relationship this past couple of years, but I can verify his performance, and he has good performance. 99.9% of these trading educators are just terrible. But a tiny little sliver are decent and honest. Reply janice April 14, 2016 Thanks for the insight Emmett it is greatly appreciated. Reply Ed Wilson April 22, 2016 Emmett In your opinion is it possible to make money day trading with any level of consistency? Thanks Ed Reply Emmett Moore April 22, 2016 Yes, but its not easy! Reply Allen April 24, 2016 Could you please review Chuck Hughes? What he writes seems correct but what is shown as examples is mostly old stuff from 2005. Plus he has won the World Cup Championship (http://www.worldcupchampionships.com/live-stats-3) 8 times, but mostly Stocks and Futures, but this may be that they don’t monitor/award for options. What he is pushing is options, through various places, one is Hughes Optionengineering. Reply John May 17, 2016 Can you recommend a school or mentor for trading the ES? I like scalping for a point but also like shooting for 2-4 point targets as well. I’ve tried several mentors but I have not found a method I can trade. It’s seems these mentors are either using lagging indicators or as with trading price action if you don’t have your trend and channel lines drawn exactly right, the market just chews you up. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated! Thanks! Reply Patrick May 27, 2016 Any thought on reviewing https://www.sanglucci.com/ ? And the “Sang Lucci” Method? Reply sam May 28, 2016 This is a strange site. Their staff roster is big which looks more like a software development company team. Two hedge funds are mentioned, “Sang Lucci Capital Partners, LP”, and “Flammarion Capital Partners, LP”. Is there a way to check how these hedge funds performed, RobB? Then one of the members is/was? a HFT trader for Flammarion. http://www.benzinga.com/markets/futures/14/11/4954773/a-day-in-the-life-of-a-high-frequency-trader correct me if I”m wrong, but I thought it was the other way where trading education vendors strive to be profitable enough to become hedge funds rather than the other way around. Otherwise it looks like the typical 225/month room and $400/$255 education videos deal. And some blog commentary on “flow” and usual after the fact comments about the general market. Reply Rob B May 28, 2016 A lot of times I think these people are just pooled money and not even a legit hedge fund. More than likely at best this is some dinky very small hedge fund, where you might have to ask them to show proof of performance. You can start by searching the SEC https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1544226/000154422614000003/0001544226-14-000003-index.htm Reply sam May 28, 2016 Thanks RobB. The address seems to be part of this office space for startups, https://www.wework.com/locations/new-york-city/nomad ; Nothing on CNBC about Lucci captial or Flammarion except Flammarion was referred to on zerohedge: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-05-29/generation-rate-hike-rookies-makes-jeff-gundlach-nervous, as a bunch of young guys watching hft algos; well I guess I could conclude like you said, small pools which hasn’t really taken off, so they chose to do “trading education” on the side ultimately becoming another vendor group. Maybe they ought to “scale down expenses” and move to the countryside farm house like Ross said he did, lol. Reply Morton Levin June 1, 2016 any traders familiar with Advanced commodity trading software Reply David June 19, 2016 What about Trading Futures in Action, with Sandy Sehgal and Bob Amico? I recall that you were planning to review them around February or March 2016 but I have not yet seen the review. They post some impressive results and claim to be doing all trades with the DOM visible. Reply Guest August 21, 2016 David, what I have seen in the room seems to be good. Here are some issues, Dr dean is in the room. And he is also in the room trade for greatness. And, he owns the trade room tradeforgreatness from April for when I reached out to April asking her that the the gains posted are amazing and if she had any proff to back those gains, and reply came back from Dr Dean. Bob Amico was charged with fraud for real estate: http://newyork.realestaterama.com/2007/11/01/amicos-plead-guilty-in-connection-with-60-million-mortgage-fraud-conspiracy-case-ID0112.html. The room just opened. If someone shows their DOM does not mean they are trading live, they can be trading simulator on the DOM. So you can go month to month but would not pay for entire year. Dr. Dean says that the best trade room is tradeforgreatness and traingfuturesinaction. And he is in both the rooms, and he emails from trade for greatness. I asked him if he says all these sites are real why does he not post their brokerage statement, that includes tradingfuturesinaction. I asked how do I know if his statements are real and if he does not get paid for his reviews and he just told me to *****. These people can can easily wipe out their account number the amount of money in that account just show the profit loss number. If they make so much money a month why do they need a petty amount of 300/mo or they can easily become a fund manager if they are that good?? Just my 2 cents Reply ZZZ June 28, 2016 Hi Emmett, your site is great. It’s awesome to see you have gone great length to reveal these scans. I have purchased a subscription from Tim Sykes in 2011 when I first started trading. Also paid another guru in the past. It’s all tuition now that I think of it. Can you take a look at Wall Street Jesus, and some of the option rooms, as well as Triforce trading, which is affiliated with Profit.ly. I know they are businesses, but would like to see your take as I have some friends who are asking me if they should pay for that, which I objected. Best, Z Reply Patrick Michael July 11, 2016 Any reviews on Academy Day Trading? Also Viper Trading Systems? Thank you Pat Reply Emmett Moore July 11, 2016 https://www.tradingschools.org/reviews/viper-trading-systems/ Still working on Academy. Reply Keith July 21, 2016 Where is the review gone of picksthatmakecents.com? or tradewithkavan.com? Emmett got paid huh ? Reply Emmett Moore July 21, 2016 I wish I got paid! That would be awesome. Kavin Klein has excited the business. As part of the deal to remove the negative review, he agreed to write me a letter that detailed everything. And I mean everything. All the good an juicy details. We agreed that the update would not be published until 30 days after he presented the letter. Basically, he talks about the entire industry and he “out’s” a lot of people. All the good stuff. But you will have to wait just a bit longer… Reply Keith July 26, 2016 How many days left to wait ? Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello Emmett can yo please respond back not sure I’m getting posted here.Tom Reply Anonymous August 1, 2016 Hello, Could you do a review on Charlie Burton’s Ezeetrader room and Jerremy Newsome’s RealLifeTrading? Charlie seems to be very consistent and has been featured on a BBC Trader documentary. He always talks about risk mitigation, which seems to be a sign that he is the real deal. However, I think one cannot join his day trading room unless his course is purchased. Thank you Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello, I came across your website and looking for some reputable stock swing trade services offering entry and exit points.Thanks in advance Tom Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello doing a test to see if this posts,please reply back.Thanks Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello,Emmett can you give me a few recommendations for a swing trade site with entry and exit points.I just tried a trial with jasonbondpicks.com.Thanks Tom Reply Rob B August 4, 2016 Tom, First I will give you credit not looking for one of these Day Trading Sites, but the odds of you following someone else entry and exit and being profitable IMO is about zero. What happens when they have a 30% pullback will you panic sell everything? You need to know why you entered into a position and know when you will exit. I have yet to meet anyone making money following someone else calls over the long term. If you are going to do that I would suggest you be better off dollar cost averaging into the several mutual funds that have a long term record of profitability. That is my 2 cents worth. My opinion worth price paid. Reply rtchoke August 4, 2016 “You need to know why you entered into a position and know when you will exit.” (from Rob B). Correct. Yep. There are two things you might want if you are a new trader. The first is you want to learn how to trade, so the moderator of the room should be showing you “if A and B, then C” giving you a clear cut picture of what is happening to get ready to trade. Then he should give you stop loss and targets (before or as he enters the trade). And he should stick to those stop loss numbers. Hold him to that. No doubling down and you need to ascertain that he’s not sim trading. The second type of learning is actually that you just want someone to give you a number and a stop and target. If that is the case, then you better be sure to get that brokerage statement for 3-6 months showing that he really knows what he’s doing. And again, no Sim, repeat several times, no sim, no sim, no sim. And I emphasize that because if he suddenly (as some TR moderator did) doubles down after being down around $1800, you have to ask if you’d do that with “real” money. Easy to do on Sim, not so easy with your hard earning money. To just hope someone will make you rich with little or no work on your part is unfortunately the dark side of the American Dream. Don’t buy into that. Trading takes skill, determination, tenacity and boldness — and lots of work. Good luck. Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello all Reply Stray Dog August 3, 2016 Hello Tom, On the right side of the homepage are two headings; “Best Trading Systems” and “Highly Ranked Trading Rooms.” The Highly Ranked Trading Rooms are probably what you are looking for. Reply JohnA August 29, 2016 Hi Emmet, I read your article on Glenridge Capital. I wish I had seen your article before I started an account with them. Their head analyst is called Ryan Daniels. Is that his real name? Is he also located in Tel Aviv? Where is their Tel Aviv office? Thanks .. John Reply John August 30, 2016 Hi Kevin, I wish I had read your article on Glenridge Capital before I started an account there. Do you know where in Israel their office is? Do you know their Head Analyst Ryan Daniels? Thanks ..J Reply Don September 3, 2016 Hi Emmett, I am in a quandary. I am in search of a futures trading room, mentor, and system. I came across your blog and website while researching trading rooms. I have spent over 9 hours reading all your reviews with two or more stars and the comments that followed them. I have got to say that you are a good writer and do a thorough job in your research. I know with all the scum out there pitching their own system you have a lot to write about. I come to realize through your blog and others that I need to very careful in selecting a mentor, system and trading room. I have been trading now for 3 years and have yet to become constantly profitable. I have tried three different systems and two trading rooms. I have read that you should not system hop, that you should stick with one system and master it. But how long is to long? I know that there is no such thing as a holy grail system but in your opinion, is there one or two systems that are better than the rest? I would like to know what system, trading room, mentor you use if any? What would your top 3-5 picks be for someone like me that has a small budget of around $3000? If I may be so bold to make a suggestion for you to consider about your website…Put your reviews in a $$ bracket. For someone like me looking for only those rooms, systems that are with in our budget. Just a observation. I look forward to your comments. PS. I would like a review on Valhalla Futures – M. William Scheier Don In Him I serve Reply Alex September 16, 2016 Hey Emmett, So where is an update review on TradewithKavan ? Reply Emmett Moore September 16, 2016 Kavan decided to “get a real job”. He contacted me and asked that I remove the review. Reply Rob B September 16, 2016 Oh this is just too funny. The guy making money hands over fist day trading, gives it up for a real job. Thanks, you gave me my laugh for the day Reply Stray Dog September 16, 2016 I wonder which job pays him better than the $20,000-$30,000 a month he was making day trading? Secret Agent? Rocket Scientist? Brain Surgeon? Boy Toy for Hillary? Or for “The Don”!!! Reply Stray Dog September 16, 2016 To be fair to Kavan I’m going to believe that he still had a conscience and once exposed the packed it in. Or maybe he was smart enough to get out before the SEC came knocking. Reply John Dakota September 16, 2016 What are your thoughts on academydaytrading.com and their pro9 software? Reply Franz September 22, 2016 Not sure what to think of this. “Every review” is a bad one. Didn’t even publish my comment regarding the Profitunity Trading Group. Actually had something nice to say about them. Reply Allen September 22, 2016 You listed a newsletter you rated highly but can not find it. Where/what is it? Reply Leon September 26, 2016 I’d be really interested in some comment or analysis of the trading room “Trading Advantage” Reply Allen September 22, 2016 Found it, but what a digging job. Reply Don Loiler September 25, 2016 Hi Emmett, I am in a quandary. I am in search of a futures trading room, mentor, and system. I came across your blog and website while researching trading rooms. I have spent over 9 hours reading all your reviews with two or more stars and the comments that followed them. I have got to say that you are a good writer and do a thorough job in your research. I know with all the scum out there pitching their own system you have a lot to write about. I come to realize through your blog and others that I need to very careful in selecting a mentor, system and trading room. I have been trading now for 3 years and have yet to become constantly profitable. I have tried three different systems and two trading rooms. I have read that you should not system hop, that you should stick with one system and master it. But how long is to long? I know that there is no such thing as a holy grail system but in your opinion, is there one or two systems that are better than the rest? I would like to know what system, trading room, mentor you use if any? What would your top 3-5 picks be for someone like me that has a small budget of around $3000? If I may be so bold to make a suggestion for you to consider about your website…Put your reviews in a $$ bracket. For someone like me looking for only those rooms, systems that are with in our budget. Just a observation. I look forward to your comments. PS. I would like a review on Valhalla Futures – M. William Scheier Don In Him I serve Reply Emmett Moore September 26, 2016 Hi Don, Forget about trading rooms. Waste of time and money. Instead, focus on backtesting strategies. Not to find out what works, but to discover what does not work. Debunking myths should be your primary goal. While you are in the process of debunking, you will slowly start to realize what actually does work. And this is the stuff that nobody is selling, or if they are selling…it costs $10k (no kidding). Download Trade Navigator Platinum. This is the backtesting and strategy testing platform for anyone that does not know how to write C#, C+, C++, .Net, or Java, etc. You can research and write strategies easily. If you are serious, I will send you a few strategies that actually work, and you can build upon that knowledge to create your strategies. Reply Don Loiler September 28, 2016 Hi Emmett, Yes, I would like the strategies you mentioned. I will download the software and start backtesting. Reply coulier patrick December 19, 2016 hello, i sruggling to be become profitable,by coincident i came to this blog and as u advised Trade Navigator Platinum i took a look at their site,it s rather expensive,so whats ur recomendation how to start out there,and can u sent me some startegies that actually work? Thanks a lot in advance Patrick Reply David September 26, 2016 Anything on Trading Futures in Action? I recall you promising a review of them sometime last winter. They still claim to show the DOM on all trades and make consistent daily profits. TraderShark is another Handley-recommended site that used to post consistent weekly positive tick totals, though without any evidence that such levels actually were achieved. Reply Rob B September 26, 2016 Really mortgage fraud Bob Amico. There have been tons of comments by people who got scammed by him in GTR and in his new room. They talked about how he mysteriously forgot his losers in his posted results. No one that can trade profitable is going to show their entries and exits as they would no longer be able to trade profitable. That is just how it works. All these day trading rooms are scams. There is not a single one that can show any proof they trade live consistently profitable. And doing a circus act where you sometimes show a DOM while trading SIM is a joke. You find a room that does the following, please let me know. But as I have repeatedly said you got a better chance of finding a Unicorn. 1) Trade an actual Live account – Sim is meaningless and as said before if you do not trust your method why would anyone else, 2) Clearly show there DOM or Chart Trader for every, not selected, trade taken, 3) Start Posting a Real Track Record Updating it Every Single Day, a. Post accurate record of your trades showing entries, exits and P/L, b. Post Brokerage Statement Proving his entries and exits. 4) Open up the Brokerage Account Live in front of people every day showing there is no trickery, and 5) Members must be able to achieve the same or close to the same results, so there is no pump and dump BS going on, 6) All members will be allowed to opening chat and no one will be banned for pointing out that I am not doing any of the promises mentioned above. Reply dtchurn September 26, 2016 Just saw that Handley mentioned Emmett in his TFIA review! lulz. his first response to the ts comments. He must have been reading ts reviews since he ditched his review integrity long ago and ts has taken the top of trusted retail trading review sites. Here at: youtu.be/iywuVmyr9s0?t=7m42s Reply dtchurn September 26, 2016 Looks like Dean Handley ~mbajdphd and TFIA are at it again. Another “hypothetical” Amico profit curve of the last year, 500% , double triple yer money etc. same ol hogwash, if Handley’s grand “tetons” of the wild snaksoily west could make those returns and newbs could follow along, he wouldn’t have to be proposing ad fees from an old home kitchen table. good recap of your rules for proof sham vendors can never follow, RobB. youtu.be/iywuVmyr9s0?t=5m28s Reply Rob B September 27, 2016 Lying Dr. Dean is the worst of the worst of the scum bags lying to the FDA during drug trials that could have caused severe injury to thousand of people as shown below. There is only one thing that matters and that is proof of profitable trading. That is what Emmett ask for, yet Dr. Dean shows absolutely no proof that any of his rooms can trade profitable or that he could trade their method profitable. All a complete circus act. If Dr. Dean was making the money he claimed from trading those rooms he surely would not be making videos from his run down kitchen. He is a complete fraud. Don’t believe me than believe the FDA. As I have repeatedly stated this whole industry is nothing but con artist. It is truely unbelievable. If the SEC stepped in all these room would be forced to close. http://securities.stanford.edu/filings-documents/1026/SEPR02-01/2003411_r01c_0212235.pdf “Dr. Handley, who was Sepracor’s Senior Director, Office of Medical Communications and Scientific Affairs, regularly represented Sepracor at hearings before the FDA and was a Sepraco r spokesman at the conference . Sepracor’s Dr. Handley stated that the cardiac effects of Soltara have been studied in several well-controlled, randomized clinical trials. He reported that “virtually no change in the Qtc interval” was observed at relatively large doses of the drug, referring to an articl e in the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology . Dr. Handley further reported that no change in Qtc interval was observed either one or two weeks into treatment that would indicate any cardiac propensity. Moreover, Dr. Handley falsely represented that “these clinical data are well substantiated b a variety of molecular, genetic and animal studies” .” Reply Don October 1, 2016 Hi Emmett, Yes, I would like the strategies you mentioned. I will download the software and start backtesting. Can I get your email address? Reply Emmett Moore October 1, 2016 you can reach me at email@example.com Reply Mike October 22, 2016 Emmett I read your review on Smart Money Room and Steve Dewitt. #1-SMR is not owned by Steve. #2-I have been in his room for the past 2 months and NEVER once did he use prerecorded data. All of his calls were LIVE. I made good money when I listened to him and lost big when I was greedy and tried to outsmart him and entered trades that were not made by him. I would not have made a dime if every trade was not live. I don’t know anything about his Forex dealings but you owe this man a serious apology for the way you defamed him. He was at least %80 right if not higher. Mike Reply Stray Dog October 23, 2016 Emmett I read your review on Smart Money Room and Steve Dewitt. #1-SMR is owned by Steve. #2-I have been in his room for the past 2 months and NEVER once did he NOT use prerecorded data. NONE of his calls were LIVE. I lost good money when I listened to him and lost even more when I was greedy and tried to be as smart as him and entered trades that were made by him. I would not have lost a dime if every trade was live. I know everything about his Forex dealings and you don’t owe this man any apology for the way you accurately described him. He was at least %80 wrong if not higher. Stray Dog PS. You can write any sh#t you like in testimonials as long as you’re not asked to prove it. Reply Mike October 23, 2016 Stray Dog How can you blatantly lie? Mike Reply Stray Dog October 23, 2016 Mike … How can you shills keep turning up on this site, spewing forth your nonsense and think that people like me are #1 going to fall for it and #2 let you get away with that sort of crap? To quote from Emmett’s review of Smart Money Room, “TradingSchools.Org reached out to Steve DeWitt, seeking verification of of the supposed 135% “fully verified” returns for 2015. Unfortunately, Steve Dewitt could not provide anything that verifies these amazing performance claims.” If DeWitt was able to shut up the critics by producing his brokerage statements to prove his claims he’d do it. He doesn’t because his claims, like yours are complete fiction. Reply Amit October 23, 2016 Agree with Stray Dog. Guys please don’t just post positive reviews about some trading room, provide proof in form of brokerage statements for atleast couple of consecutive months along with your post otherwise you are just wasting your time. Any person reading posts without proof should just ignore such posts as fake advertising. Reply Jason November 7, 2016 Any good ones to recommend for Forex? Reply Pete November 14, 2016 Hi Emmett – any thought of doing a review on LiveTraders.com? They do publish results, but whether they tie up with reality I have no idea. Reply Fake Reviews November 27, 2016 The only honest thing to say about your reviews is that you are the one misleading people, what a scam. Don’t publish this comment, you won’t because you are another waste of the internet… adding more garbage to the world of fake, crap, useless information out there. I am going to make sure I add this to the 450+ sites around the web which I am affiliated with to let people know your reviews are garbage, backed by your fake motives and affiliations. Regardless, maybe you are live for another few months anyway, since you won’t make money from this site and you will ultimately give up and hide back in your grandmothers basement. Get a life and take your crap site back to scam world you created. Reply Joe December 10, 2016 Can you please review the following traders: http://livetraders.com/ They post monthly results on their site. Please review to see if they are fake or legit. Thank you Reply Florencio Moreno January 6, 2017 Any reviews on David Frost’s LazyGapTrader/MyStrategicForecast? Reply Leave a Reply Cancel reply If A New Comment Is Posted:Do Not Send Email Notifications.Send Email Notification ONLY If Someone Replies To My Comment(s).Send Email Notification Whenever A New Comment Is Posted.