Review Team 324 Comments « Older Comments Newer Comments » Ed Wilson April 22, 2016 Emmett In your opinion is it possible to make money day trading with any level of consistency? Thanks Ed Reply Emmett Moore April 22, 2016 Yes, but its not easy! Reply Allen April 24, 2016 Could you please review Chuck Hughes? What he writes seems correct but what is shown as examples is mostly old stuff from 2005. Plus he has won the World Cup Championship (http://www.worldcupchampionships.com/live-stats-3) 8 times, but mostly Stocks and Futures, but this may be that they don’t monitor/award for options. What he is pushing is options, through various places, one is Hughes Optionengineering. Reply John May 17, 2016 Can you recommend a school or mentor for trading the ES? I like scalping for a point but also like shooting for 2-4 point targets as well. I’ve tried several mentors but I have not found a method I can trade. It’s seems these mentors are either using lagging indicators or as with trading price action if you don’t have your trend and channel lines drawn exactly right, the market just chews you up. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated! Thanks! Reply Patrick May 27, 2016 Any thought on reviewing https://www.sanglucci.com/ ? And the “Sang Lucci” Method? Reply sam May 28, 2016 This is a strange site. Their staff roster is big which looks more like a software development company team. Two hedge funds are mentioned, “Sang Lucci Capital Partners, LP”, and “Flammarion Capital Partners, LP”. Is there a way to check how these hedge funds performed, RobB? Then one of the members is/was? a HFT trader for Flammarion. http://www.benzinga.com/markets/futures/14/11/4954773/a-day-in-the-life-of-a-high-frequency-trader correct me if I”m wrong, but I thought it was the other way where trading education vendors strive to be profitable enough to become hedge funds rather than the other way around. Otherwise it looks like the typical 225/month room and $400/$255 education videos deal. And some blog commentary on “flow” and usual after the fact comments about the general market. Reply Rob B May 28, 2016 A lot of times I think these people are just pooled money and not even a legit hedge fund. More than likely at best this is some dinky very small hedge fund, where you might have to ask them to show proof of performance. You can start by searching the SEC https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1544226/000154422614000003/0001544226-14-000003-index.htm Reply sam May 28, 2016 Thanks RobB. The address seems to be part of this office space for startups, https://www.wework.com/locations/new-york-city/nomad ; Nothing on CNBC about Lucci captial or Flammarion except Flammarion was referred to on zerohedge: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-05-29/generation-rate-hike-rookies-makes-jeff-gundlach-nervous, as a bunch of young guys watching hft algos; well I guess I could conclude like you said, small pools which hasn’t really taken off, so they chose to do “trading education” on the side ultimately becoming another vendor group. Maybe they ought to “scale down expenses” and move to the countryside farm house like Ross said he did, lol. Morton Levin June 1, 2016 any traders familiar with Advanced commodity trading software David June 19, 2016 What about Trading Futures in Action, with Sandy Sehgal and Bob Amico? I recall that you were planning to review them around February or March 2016 but I have not yet seen the review. They post some impressive results and claim to be doing all trades with the DOM visible. Reply Guest August 21, 2016 David, what I have seen in the room seems to be good. Here are some issues, Dr dean is in the room. And he is also in the room trade for greatness. And, he owns the trade room tradeforgreatness from April for when I reached out to April asking her that the the gains posted are amazing and if she had any proff to back those gains, and reply came back from Dr Dean. Bob Amico was charged with fraud for real estate: http://newyork.realestaterama.com/2007/11/01/amicos-plead-guilty-in-connection-with-60-million-mortgage-fraud-conspiracy-case-ID0112.html. The room just opened. If someone shows their DOM does not mean they are trading live, they can be trading simulator on the DOM. So you can go month to month but would not pay for entire year. Dr. Dean says that the best trade room is tradeforgreatness and traingfuturesinaction. And he is in both the rooms, and he emails from trade for greatness. I asked him if he says all these sites are real why does he not post their brokerage statement, that includes tradingfuturesinaction. I asked how do I know if his statements are real and if he does not get paid for his reviews and he just told me to *****. These people can can easily wipe out their account number the amount of money in that account just show the profit loss number. If they make so much money a month why do they need a petty amount of 300/mo or they can easily become a fund manager if they are that good?? Just my 2 cents Reply ZZZ June 28, 2016 Hi Emmett, your site is great. It’s awesome to see you have gone great length to reveal these scans. I have purchased a subscription from Tim Sykes in 2011 when I first started trading. Also paid another guru in the past. It’s all tuition now that I think of it. Can you take a look at Wall Street Jesus, and some of the option rooms, as well as Triforce trading, which is affiliated with Profit.ly. I know they are businesses, but would like to see your take as I have some friends who are asking me if they should pay for that, which I objected. Best, Z Reply Patrick Michael July 11, 2016 Any reviews on Academy Day Trading? Also Viper Trading Systems? Thank you Pat Reply Emmett Moore July 11, 2016 https://www.tradingschools.org/reviews/viper-trading-systems/ Still working on Academy. Reply Keith July 21, 2016 Where is the review gone of picksthatmakecents.com? or tradewithkavan.com? Emmett got paid huh ? Reply Emmett Moore July 21, 2016 I wish I got paid! That would be awesome. Kavin Klein has excited the business. As part of the deal to remove the negative review, he agreed to write me a letter that detailed everything. And I mean everything. All the good an juicy details. We agreed that the update would not be published until 30 days after he presented the letter. Basically, he talks about the entire industry and he “out’s” a lot of people. All the good stuff. But you will have to wait just a bit longer… Reply Keith July 26, 2016 How many days left to wait ? Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello Emmett can yo please respond back not sure I’m getting posted here.Tom Reply Anonymous August 1, 2016 Hello, Could you do a review on Charlie Burton’s Ezeetrader room and Jerremy Newsome’s RealLifeTrading? Charlie seems to be very consistent and has been featured on a BBC Trader documentary. He always talks about risk mitigation, which seems to be a sign that he is the real deal. However, I think one cannot join his day trading room unless his course is purchased. Thank you Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello, I came across your website and looking for some reputable stock swing trade services offering entry and exit points.Thanks in advance Tom Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello doing a test to see if this posts,please reply back.Thanks Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello,Emmett can you give me a few recommendations for a swing trade site with entry and exit points.I just tried a trial with jasonbondpicks.com.Thanks Tom Reply Rob B August 4, 2016 Tom, First I will give you credit not looking for one of these Day Trading Sites, but the odds of you following someone else entry and exit and being profitable IMO is about zero. What happens when they have a 30% pullback will you panic sell everything? You need to know why you entered into a position and know when you will exit. I have yet to meet anyone making money following someone else calls over the long term. If you are going to do that I would suggest you be better off dollar cost averaging into the several mutual funds that have a long term record of profitability. That is my 2 cents worth. My opinion worth price paid. Reply rtchoke August 4, 2016 “You need to know why you entered into a position and know when you will exit.” (from Rob B). Correct. Yep. There are two things you might want if you are a new trader. The first is you want to learn how to trade, so the moderator of the room should be showing you “if A and B, then C” giving you a clear cut picture of what is happening to get ready to trade. Then he should give you stop loss and targets (before or as he enters the trade). And he should stick to those stop loss numbers. Hold him to that. No doubling down and you need to ascertain that he’s not sim trading. The second type of learning is actually that you just want someone to give you a number and a stop and target. If that is the case, then you better be sure to get that brokerage statement for 3-6 months showing that he really knows what he’s doing. And again, no Sim, repeat several times, no sim, no sim, no sim. And I emphasize that because if he suddenly (as some TR moderator did) doubles down after being down around $1800, you have to ask if you’d do that with “real” money. Easy to do on Sim, not so easy with your hard earning money. To just hope someone will make you rich with little or no work on your part is unfortunately the dark side of the American Dream. Don’t buy into that. Trading takes skill, determination, tenacity and boldness — and lots of work. Good luck. Reply Tom August 3, 2016 Hello all Reply Stray Dog August 3, 2016 Hello Tom, On the right side of the homepage are two headings; “Best Trading Systems” and “Highly Ranked Trading Rooms.” The Highly Ranked Trading Rooms are probably what you are looking for. Reply JohnA August 29, 2016 Hi Emmet, I read your article on Glenridge Capital. I wish I had seen your article before I started an account with them. Their head analyst is called Ryan Daniels. Is that his real name? Is he also located in Tel Aviv? Where is their Tel Aviv office? Thanks .. John Reply John August 30, 2016 Hi Kevin, I wish I had read your article on Glenridge Capital before I started an account there. Do you know where in Israel their office is? Do you know their Head Analyst Ryan Daniels? Thanks ..J Reply « Older Comments Newer Comments » Leave a Reply Cancel reply Yes, add me to your mailing list This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.