Live Trading Rooms Sending User Review 0 (0 votes) Embed code <iframe frameborder="0" width="500" height="500" src="https://www.tradingschools.org/?wp_review_id=43"></iframe> 326 Comments « Older Comments Newer Comments » Idan December 18, 2016 Hi Emmett, First, you are doing a great job! Thank you very much for that. Do you have something on TimothySykes.com? Thanks! Reply AJ March 22, 2017 Hi Emmitt, Any chance we could ask you to review Meir Barak from TradeNet. He has alot of videos on YouTube executing large trades with the most recent one showing the last few years worth of P/L’s directly from his Colemax account. Thank you, AJ Reply Rob B May 1, 2017 Emmett, This post is to you. After looking at GZT videos and going back and forth with shill Paul (and believe me that is being nice) I have no doubt that GZT is yet another scam that is suckering people out of $7,00 for a complete BS course that shows Supply and Demand areas just like Sam Sieden. My question is have you done a review of this TR? If not I think it is time to ask this con artist TR operator for proof of this claims ( I know you already did) and put it in its own thread with a complete review. Then moron shill Paul and his aliases can continue to post in that thread how this TR is the real deal and continue to never show any proof. But at least a complete review will have been posted. Now surely Paul cannot be against this. Reply Emmett Moore May 1, 2017 Alrighty then. Am getting on it right now. Reply Tom May 2, 2017 Just love how you can beat the snakes out of the grass with a few questions. I really want a review of James Dalton .. His name has been hitting my mailbox alot lately and the self proclaimed “FATHER OF MARKET PROFILE THEORY ” sticks in my craw … I know a deeper dive into this clownass will prove he’s another Grey haired “I’ve been around for decades so Im trustworthy” scammmer who sells education and doesnt trade a real account using his own bullshit… He also been doing alot of stuff through Think or Swim for free, no doubt see’s the potential of thousands of sheep who will gladly pay a couple grand for some MP3 files and a train load of bullshit … Reply Rob B May 2, 2017 Pete, Dtchum and other alias you use, I am going to make a Mid-Year Resolution. Even though your posts are unique (see I am being nice) for the most part you are not shilling for a Con Artist TR like GZT, telling folks if they buy there $7,000 course they too will be a Master Student and make a fortune, while never showing any proof of that claim like some unnamed shills are doing here. So as long as you are not shilling or attacking me to where I feel compelled to reply, I will try my best to not reply to any more of your post no matter how unique I think they are. **** Darn I Hope I Can Still to this Mid Year Resolution **** Reply dtchum May 2, 2017 I hope you are a person of your word. But experience tells me you will not stop attacking me, and Pete too. I trust nothing you say. Reply dtchurn May 2, 2017 RobB said “So as long as you are not shilling or attacking” but history has proven over 30 reviews without a doubt guttersnipes like peete=toto=drNo/drChump keep buzzing back with inane posts like annoying & pestering mosquitoes. Reply Stray Dog May 2, 2017 You’re too nice Rob B. This twat began his mindless attacks for no reason and with no provocation. Reply Emmett Moore May 2, 2017 You gotta laugh at some of the bickering that takes place on this blog. https://youtu.be/YMkfEKno5Co Reply Mike M May 2, 2017 That’s a great video. Fly the friendly skies. Pete May 2, 2017 Thank you Emmett for serving the meds to the lunatic wolfpack. Can we please get a review of the deceased Jack Hershey / Elitetrader forums. I have traced the genesis of Dr. A to this deceased cult leader / charlatan. dtchum May 2, 2017 Ahhh you are such a good and loyal companion to Mr. “I hate Dr. A, but mention him in posts every chance I get.” Good Boy! My question for you: will you ever post anything besides just replying to your owner’s posts? Reply Stray Dog May 2, 2017 dtchump AKA Pete, AKA dtchurnNO AKA toto Do you have anything to contribute to the discussion about TR vendors or is your sole purpose here going to be to continue to tag dtchurn’s posts, to assume different personas in order to create the illusion that there is support for your off topic posts or to continue to get angry because you can’t garner sympathy for being stupid and losing money trading that you got from a high interest loan? Rob B May 2, 2017 Stray Dog, It is not about being nice. Here is how I figure it. You only got so much energy to spend and if the poster is just posting odd and unusual things (trying to be positive) there is nothing I can post that will make them see the light. So if they are not shilling and trying to sucker people into some con artist trading room, what do I care. Be and let be is my new motto. I just hope they don’t start to post about some unrelated topic like fashion. Reply Mike M May 2, 2017 Rob I think that is your next calling, fashion critic. Watch out for those that offer low quality fashion made from cheap material and sell it to people willing to pay exorbitant prices. Fashion week in NYC will never be the same. dtchurn May 2, 2017 For sure, the little guttersnipe gollum all too often suddenly rages in a mental fit and takes tagalong peashots after emerging from the cesspool of his hole trying to drag sensible posters to his quite unique but oafal level. Reply dtchum May 3, 2017 Get To Know Frequent Commenters On This Board… Name: Stray Habits: unquestioned loyalty to his employer and master. Never an original thought. Will defend employer at all costs. Reply dtchum May 3, 2017 For those of you new to this site, when reading Rob’s rants please remember he also wrote this UNEDITED comment snippet on the Page Trader thread: “I hear there is this chap named Al Brooks taking on new members that I am sure can cure you.” It is important to realize Rob’s motivation$$$. Let the denials begin, Rob… Reply dtchurn May 3, 2017 For those new to this site, ignore the ignoramus dr.Chump twisting of the history of RobB’s tireless vanguard vigilance over the shills and trolls who try to take over the commentary. Here is the actual post, grossly taken out of context where dr.chump disrespects the faculties of the sane readership by attempting to spread falsehood pretentiously assuming no new readers would actually go back and find those words and the post. (RobB back in pagetrader: ) “” Well it is obvious I could not be a Physiologist, as I could not help you out of your delusional state. Maybe Prozac, I don’t know. I am done talking to the mentally disturbed Pete. It is obvious the TR have done a serious number on your head worst than your $20K in losses. Maybe someone else can help you. Oh, I know I hear there is this chap named Al Brooks taking on new members that I am sure can cure you. “”” And the post RobB’s post is replying to is just bonkers. have fun. Reply dtchum May 3, 2017 Churn’s Stealth Guide To Internet Marketing Step 1: Bash every vendor and room on the site, regardless of what Emmett says. COMPLETED Step 2: Mock, ridicule and bully anyone (Pete, others) who has lost money trading. Establish air of arrogance COMPLETED Step 3: Boast of own profitability. Ignore requests to show proof. Establish Air of Authority. COMPLETED Step 4: Threaten to leave site forever when questioned. Return and hope people forgot about lack of proof for earlier boastful profit claims. COMPLETED Step 5: Unveil trading product for sale. TBD Step 6: Deny all steps above. ONGOING How is Step 5 coming along Churn? Oh I forgot your response will always be Step 6. My Skype trading group has a betting pool for the date your trading product will come out. We all know it is coming soon… Reply dtchurn May 3, 2017 dr. Chum’s faux steps of supporting the shills and trolls step 1: Attempt to undermine just reaction of commenters upon discovering every scam and sham exposed in succession in review after review the retail scam world is much worse than was led to believe before Tradingschools and the fact Emmett freely acknowledged being misled and fooled in the past and acknowleding challenging comments. In fact, more than a few reviews were drastically updated motivated by new info from comments or messages to Emmett such as the CFRN., DTP, Rightline, etc. reviews. It takes a shill poster like you to be an ignoramus of the accomplished history of tradingschools which you actually demonstrate little respect for. step2: take on the side of instigators like Pete who bring discussion to a gutter and ludicrous level. completely ignore the past history of more than 40 reviews and hundreds of mental b__ks posting and enraged tripe over those who call out the mental bs and distraction. step3: make a ludicrous “step” based on irrelevant and idiotic demands of a non-vendor commenter who is not selling anything. Makes one wonder what drchump’s true mission is possibly to attempt to undermine the anti-shill vanguard so the forum gets freely overrun by shill comments like every other compromised forum. step4: falsely equate taking a break with leaving forever. conveniently ignore Pete’s broken vow in pagetrader in his supposed last post which he tried to continue sneaking by via toto and alters and now speaking to himself as dr.Chum. idiotically thinking sane people won’t notice drchump and gollum-peet in cahoots step 5: hilarious imagination of a retail trading product based on thin air. step 6: making up a staircase steps of falling cards based of irrelavancy thinking it amounts to anything to dissuade from the witchhunt mission of tradingschools and it’s commenters to bring the exposure these shamsters deserve after getting away with it from compromised sites and forums for years. Enjoy your continued dream factory in your sykpe losers group of yapping toto/petedetithb__ks,/wet towel tradingfratboy and his pathetic rental license plate blotting,/drNo, et al.. The sane readership can easily see the cheese holes in your lame tripped up series of mis-steps. Reply dtchum May 3, 2017 Methinks thou dost protest too much. Just sayin’ Reply Stray Dog May 3, 2017 dtchump Methinks, and I’m confident regular readers of this blog think, that you have very real and untreated psychological issues. You need to seek medical help or at the very least counseling. dtchum May 3, 2017 Stray – your nick is so appropriate. You are loyal and always obedient to your masters churn Rob and cyn. Hopefully you never need to think for yourself, because then you’ll end up in the pound. Cyn May 3, 2017 One should never argue with an unintelligent stupid idiot, because onlookers might not be able to tell the difference. Which is why so far I have ignored your continued digs at me. And I shall continue so to do. dtchum May 3, 2017 Cy: “so far I have ignored your continued digs at me. And I shall continue so to do.” Except, of course, when you don’t ignore the comments. Congratulations, you have reached Credibility Level Zero dtchurn May 3, 2017 Stray has been another tireless vanguard watchdog and independent bite voicing the sane readership reaction and sentiment. And Cyn is also another independent commenter of reason. Which is far more than can be said of singular nonsensical shills and trolls who often use alters to try to drum up irrelevant smokescreen distraction and illusory faux solidarity. Cyn June 18, 2017 You must be too stupid to understand the phrase: “so far”. Since you are that stupid, I will help you out. It means: “all the way until this time, when I am actually not ignoring you”. Go back to school and learn something, you twerp. Stray Dog May 3, 2017 You mistake loyalty for agreement. On many issues I agree with what they people you have associated me with say. This is probably because we share similar characteristic, the chief one being sanity. Michael May 10, 2017 Hi, Has anyone done a review of https//www.flippingwallstreet.com ? If not, can someone please do an honest review of it ? Thanks, Mike Reply James June 18, 2017 I’m interested in actually OPENING a live pay-per-view futures trading room, legit live calls of course. No hanky panky, just honest calls LIVE. I know taking a risk posting here about this HERE but I seriously am seeking advice on how to proceed. What is the first things I should do, how do I get started? Need help with legal stuff as well as marketing etc. Building the website (what legal disclaimers do I need for example), can I do this myself with a free website builder?? Why do I want to this? Trading is stressful day in and day out, like being self-employed. subscription service is more like a biz, like owning a Dominos pizza store. Also, I want to help other retail traders make some $, for 299/month (or 599?) I make $ they get a chance of making $? I know you guys hate & distrust vendors, but is there room for a legit subscription trading room, and if so how should I do it? Thanks Reply Mike M June 18, 2017 James, good luck posting that here. No one here that I read believes a trading room can provide any value for many reasons. Most traders are under funded and attempt to trade day to day noise. IMO, sometimes there are 3-5 trades a week at best worth the risk in the ES contract and that’s a decent week. That goes against running a TR where subscribers expect 90 percent accuracy with multiple calls a day and very little draw downs. Of course there are exceptions, but that has been proven elusive for Emmett to find and this is after how many years. Reply Rob B June 18, 2017 “I know you guys hate & distrust vendors, but is there room for a legit subscription trading room, and if so how should I do it?” Sure, here is what you do first. Show proof you have been consistently trading live profitable over a long period of time. No Excel spreadsheets. No take your word on it. No showing your winners and forgetting your losers. No BS sim trading. Show live brokerage statements!!! But here is the bottom line if you could really trade profitable then the last thing in the world you would do is open a trading room, as the second others took the exact same trade at the same time your edge is lost. So call me doubtful of your claims. Reply Mike M June 18, 2017 Rob B., man I love the entertainment you provide with your responses. The amount pf energy you possess and the intestinal fortitude to keep it real is commendable. I sure hope some investigators at the DOJ feel the same way towards trading sites. Reply dtchurn June 18, 2017 Is this serious? I wonder if you’re aware the stated details of your room plan sounds pretty much the same m.o. that most of these trading rooms cliam down to the monthly churning fee. Alex Sobeil/Seilaf pretty much said the same thing many reviews back. We even saw his monthly fee goals targeting newbs in his student draft for his web school. Tradingschools, as a result of digging into the inner shady workings of these sham rooms has pretty much shown how they operate and the setup looks fairly simple. You can see most of the sites reviewed with a trading room cost $150 to $500 per month, with the median being $300/month. Perusing now grand teton’s mortgage fraud Amico’s room as an example, all that is needed is a slap- on of the CFTC 4.41 disclaimer to cover the simshow trading, and paypal links to monthly subscriptions. http://www.tradingfuturesinaction.com/membership Then all is needed is a webinar service such as gotomeeting and an email mass mailing list. All the usual advertising methods they use are pretty much exposed throughout the many reviews here. Reply James June 18, 2017 LOL dude…. there are no rules. It’s basically a wild west with no regulation. You can pretty much say anything you want and nothing will happen to you. The only risk is that in the future, should regulators start to crack down, you could be in some trouble. Having said that no one here is going to give you advice on how to set up your scam. Don’t expect any vendors to give any advice either…. they don’t want any extra competition! Funny how they’ll give out market advice left and right without any fear of edge dilution, but when it comes to the details of their vendor business they are pretty tight-lipped! LOL! (different guy, same name, and definitely not Pete– LOL!!) Reply Mike M June 18, 2017 James II so true. You can make the most outrageous claims and you will probably have some decent traffic to a site at first. They obviously aren’t concerned with edge dilution because on SIM I don’t think that’s a concern. I do find it entertaining when these clowns go on you tube to warn the retail investor about the fake ones when looking for an educator. They talk about all the inflated claims of results. I really think they start to believe their own bs. Reply dtchurn June 18, 2017 Yep, MikeM, James-II, some of them preach to the choir like they are not only a trading sham guru , but an “authority” on spotting other trading scams trying to smokescreen a fog of legitimacy, of course very close to the truth as to how they would know lol. Preston James, one of the options “monthly income” shammeisters had this long “manifesto” about trading education scams he would send to prospective subscribers. Mike M June 19, 2017 dtchurn, keep calling them out on their nonsense. It’s enjoyable, but unfortunately still not nearly enough. Until the regulators create a mandate to take down these trading websites, the farce will continue. Rob B June 19, 2017 James, OK, being no one else is going to help you, I will step in and show you how to be the best low life scammer out there. I can see the hate mail now for me helping you. BTW everything I am going to show you I have seen done by the best of the best con artist Trading Room (TR) Operators out there. In fact I should really be charging you for this information as other scammer are doing just this to make millions (Please Read Disclaimer). Here goes: 1) Confidence – Look into the mirror and say I will be the best darn scammer ever. I will make Madoff look like penny-ante shit compared to me. Ruthless, heartless and low life confidence is king when leading the sheep to the slaughter, 2) Shills – You will need lots shills or alias (the more the marrier). These alias will be busy and do several important tasks (they are like your pawns in chess). BTW I should add something here. To be the best of the best con artist is not easy. You will have to work to be the best: a. The alias will post on every review site like invest-o-scam-u and say how you turned their life around. They will say they went from one room to another and nothing helped until they met you and how they are now able to make a living day trading and then give personal thank you note to you. It helps if they talk about some made up story like having sick kids or how they just lost their job and were in financial trouble, b. The shills will post during your webinar how they just hit it out of the park on your last call, c. When another Dick Head post, let’s say Rob B, in the text box that your last trade lost money and shows the actual facts, the shill will post, “What the hell is Rob B smoking” and then say how they made money on that trade, and d. The shill will come to sites like this and relentless post promotional BS ads again and again. 3) Trader Porn – You will need Trader Porn or pictures of you with models and jet planes and Lamborghinis and heck Stray Dog had one with his servant cleaning a gold toilet, that one is great. If you need more help on this one just go to IP sites and watch Amy. In fact maybe hire Amy as a consultant. She is a great scammer. But the best of the best is Ross – hands down. 4) Now Listen Carefully as this one is the Greatest Tip ever. You need to pay someone, the VIG, to supposedly independent trading room evaluators, such as Lying Dean Handley or Emmett to give you a great review – You get this and you are set, so don’t be cheap with the Vig, 5) You will take acting lessons. This one is more important than you think – I will explain later, 6) Now on how to run the actual Trading Room: a. There are several options here. But one way is to create a circus of misdirection. The best way to do that is have 3 traders running the room. That way you are basically each other’s shill. It will always be the person off mic who calls the winning trade and the one on mic saying how the other guy just had another home run and of course the shills will be chiming in big time bragging about their non-existent winning trades, b. During your webinar you will always be showing hindsight trades that one could have easily taken if they just bought your education package and again this is where the shills come in. So Shill Tom say, “just made 20 ticks on that trade”, and you state you too would have seen that trade if you had bought my education package for $6500. And here is a great place to talk about how Tom was having financial problems until he met you – Remember you are the Mother Teresa of Day TRs I will expand more on this below, c. This is important – your goal is to be laughing all the way to the bank and in order to get the sheep to the slaughter you will have to sound sympathetic. During your webinar talk about how you too could not pay your bills until someone taught you how to day trade and now you just feel you must give back and help others. Blah, Blah, Blah. You must convince them you are the Mother Teresa of Day Trading. Those acting lessons were for a reason. d. You will pay someone to create a really lenient sim fill generator. So you actually get positive slippage and for goodness sake you will never show any commissions. e. Even though you are trading Sim, pretend you are trading live. You will brag everywhere from the real world to kingdom come over your winners and your losers will always be well that was just a small loss or not mention them at all. You will send out emails to everyone about your “BIG” Winner and light up the web at Stock Twits and Twitter. f. This part is ingenious as I have seen TRs now doing it due to sites like this one. Again you get a programmer so you can display your Sim Trades and make them look like they came from a brokerage account. You will call them Snippets. Again you show these Snippets like there is no tomorrow on a winner. This is where your acting lessons will really come in handy. g. This one is Golden and Icing on the Cake. It is sooo good I hate to give it out. Again there are several ways to do it. You will show the sheep how you are trading live and turning a small $1000 account into $8000 or whatever number. i. Option 1 – You can use Trader Vu to do this. You go to your Brokerage Account and download a file. Then you upload your fake trade file into Trader Vu and show all your fake winning trades – again acting lessons (and you thought those acting lessons were silly), ii. Again with the programmer. You can fake anything you want, just have them create a program that makes it look like you are opening a real brokerage account and showing live trading results, iii. Finally, this is the one that I think is the most powerful. It will cost you money, but you have to think of the cost as advertising cost. Remember you will be blasting this on Youtube, StockTwist, Twitter and so forth, so you will get your money’s worth. And your scam is going to make you millions so you can afford to spend some advertising money. Remember to be the best of the best scammer out there it is work and brilliance (these guys are not dumb or lazy). For this scam, you will open many small accounts. If you are just starting start smaller. But for example let’s say you open 50 $1000 accounts or a $50,000 investment. And you actually trade those accounts live. Now 90% of them will go bust and overall you will lose most of this money, but by sure Gaussian distribution one of them will make money. And let’s say you only luck out and double one of the accounts in 3 months. So you lost $49,000 in 49 accounts and make $1000 in one account. You take that one single account that made 100% return in 3 month and you go to town as I mentioned before. Everyone will be talking about how you doubled your money in 3 months and you will have a line of suckers lining up to join your complete BS TR as you laugh all the way to the bank. h. Disclaimer – You will include a disclaimer that the results are hypothetical or whatever the latest regulated disclaimer that is required. Yes I see the hate mail coming in now. So why did I show this guy how to scam folks, because this is exactly what the best of the best Day TRs are doing right now and if you do not know their tricks you too will be the goat. Lastly, I could go on days with this and I left a lot out. This is only a small portion of the scammer’s toolkit. Lastly after writing this I think I need a Disclaimer. Disclaimer: The goal of this post is to educate people and make them aware of the tricks the Day Trading Room Operators use to scam them out of your money. There is no intention here to get anyone to open a Day TR and scam folks out of their money. This is for educational purposes only. One last comment I have offered on many occasions to show Emmett my brokerage statement to show I trade profitably, when I do trade, if he gave me a thread. By the way my returns are real world returns not the fantasy nonsense the Day TR promise. This is the kind of stuff I would have in my thread letting folks know how the scammer’s work. It would be nice if it was in one place so people could use it for reference. Reply Mike M June 19, 2017 I swear, these posts have become my daily entertainment. Great stuff!! Every moment I get a chance I look forward to a good story. Reply James II June 19, 2017 I’ll probably never do it. Been mulling it over for awhile now, but if I do the room will be 110% legit. I would welcome a review by Emmett. Have NO interest in selling courses for “4,990” or teaching people to trade or crap like that. All “calls” nothing more, nothing fancy. Good solid LIVE calls. Period. No Guarntees. Nothing more. No SIM. I would take same trades as my subscribers. They see me place the trade, then I would also announce it in audio. “Buy ES limit blah blah. Stop blah blah. 1st trgt blah blah” Something on order of this. I’d get a big kick out of helping struggling trades make a dime or two. I don’t want to teach anyone to fish, justwhen to yank the rod. however, should one of subscribers have a problem taking the calls, I’d genuinely be interested in helping them to solve the problem, take the calls properly and hopefully make a little $. One thing, how would this dilute my edge or my profitability as someone here suggested? Reply Rob B June 19, 2017 ES more liquid than most, so can have a few subscribers matching your calls and not effect edge; maybe. So you will only be making money off the monthly churn. Again when it come to TR I am always suspicious as I see many also sell their private 1 on 1 teachings for extra money. Limit orders are so easy to scam. You get filled when no one else does and so forth. You did not mention the most important thing and that was a commitment to clearly show your written down calls (entry, stop loss and profit target) and not voiced BS calls that can be made to make anything a winner and then to open a live brokerage account right in front of everyone showing you took those calls so everyone can see your slippage your commissions and no BS snippet views. I know those are sim BS nonsense. Perfect example Dekmar Trades who does not even trade his own alerts and then opens the infamous BS snippet tool. Also you have not stated a single thing about your trading method. Are you scalping ES for 4 ticks 20 times a day or what. But my most important question is if you can trade the ES consistently profitably why are you not managing money or working for GS or running a hedge fund and being paid 100s’ of millions like the other managers who can not even beat the S&P. Gosh I forget, you want to give back. How could I forget. I tell you want open your room and have 1 month free trial and I will join and report what I see. And if you are legit and killing it trading ES in no time you will have a 1000 subscribers all taking the exact same trade at the exact same time. Reply Mike M June 19, 2017 James, I would also try your room if you offer a free trial. I watch the ES daily and trade when I believe there is an opportunity. However, I only trade when I believe there is an above average risk reward opportunity which doesn’t come around too often IMO. Even then, I may get stopped on 60 percent of my trades taken that week. On the other hand, I may only trade twice for the whole week. The ES is so liquid which means taking the offer or hitting the bid won’t provide slippage most of the time. If you play the limit game I believe that would be one knock against you already. If you provide true value trading live with your entries, exits and stops clearly defined then you can expect more subscribers than you can handle. Reply JamesII June 19, 2017 Emmett, I like your site and have been lurking here for awhile. I apologize for my initial post, just wanted an opinion on the possiblity legit room. I’ll likely never do it and just keep trading my own acct. My last post here, but I’ll keep reading. Reply Rob B June 19, 2017 If you are legit, then you certainly realize most TR are nothing but a scam and be willing to show you are legit as I have outlined. But instead you seem to be saying you are going to tuck your tail between your legs and run. Hmm, does not sound legit to me. Stand up to the challenge. Open that TR up with a 1 month free trial and let us all see just how legit you are. Now someone legit should not have any issue with that. Should they? I just find it funny the second I started to state you need to show real live brokerage statements instead of standing up and saying, “Damn straight I will be showing them” you disappear into the wood work. Give me a break James, JamesII, James II (with a space) . Reply James II June 19, 2017 IMO, doesn’t take a month of trades to tell a legit trader, about 5 trading days would do it assuming enough trades. I know I won’t do it, but if I did no month free, or even a week but get your money back if you are not profitable after a month, or for whatever reason. no questions asked. there won’t be too many redeemers, imo, but could be wrong. Reply Rob B June 19, 2017 IMO you cannot even begin to tell if a trader is truly consistently profitable in a month. But if you are the real deal what is there to fear? The 1 month free trail will get you more subscribers than you know what you to do with and as you show them how to trade profitably and they are making money they will be more than willing to pay the monthly churn. Seems like a win win for a legit room. Why would there be an hesitation, after-all you came here for suggestions, Did you not? But being you have not respond to a single legit question asked of you such as provide some actual details about your trading or how you will show proof you are “Truly” legit, count me dubious. In fact Mike M you want to make a side bet on this guy being legit? JamesII June 19, 2017 Rob B, always love your replies. I am so sorry I even brought this up here. Reply James II June 19, 2017 i’m up 300 today, one contract 3 trades just saying Reply Emmett Moore June 19, 2017 Alright! Great job James. Reply Rob B June 19, 2017 OK, this is a joke. Very Funny. No one could be stupid enough to post this complete nonsense dribble here. Very Funny. I hope this is not another Alex and what was it called gravity something TR nonsense. Reply James II June 19, 2017 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2V1avjxRdo Reply James II June 19, 2017 ended the day up almost 500, is that a joke i guess so i’ll take it Reply Rob B June 19, 2017 No I would call it BS promotional nonsense ahead of a website. Unbelievable came here talking about starting a website and now this crap. Let me take a crack. Darn tootin I made $2500 Today scalping the heck out of CL. Golly Be. Like Real, $2500 in the first hour of trading. My word is my corn feed mouth truth. Proof is for suckers. And bless the lord I am going to allow the first 100 folks to sign up for my $299/ month room. Ya’ll come now! You will have more fun than a tornado in mobile home park. James you have shown your self to be a complete POS. Go to stocktwits to post your nonsense. Maybe you read the top of this thread as, “James BS Fake Trading Profits Calls to sucker in the suckers” Sorry Mike M. Do you think this is too harsh!!!! I am still offering that side bet. Reply James II June 19, 2017 I’m not posting “ahead of a website”, i doubt i’ll ever do it. I created 500 bucks out of nothing but candles, not 2500 (i wish) i’m proud of that. Reply Emmett Moore June 19, 2017 As you should be. I am proud of you James! Dont worry about Rob. He barks at me too. Rob B June 19, 2017 “I am proud of you James! ” Really is your goal to become the new StockTwits were con artist post their nonsense trades and then links to their TRs. If so prepare for thousand of trade posted to this site. Of course from a business prospectus it probably makes good economical sense. A picture is worth a 1000 words that convey my response. Emmett Moore June 19, 2017 And I’m proud of you too Rob, for only losing $1000 today. Lol! Rob B June 20, 2017 Yes, I pull out my crystal ball and see I will lose $1000 on James Guaranteed $500 ES trades today. dtchurn June 19, 2017 I think Emmett is just having fun with the trollish tone. I would hope the ts comments won’t be devolved into shams shilling out daily simbucked trade results and calls. The poor bigcat looks like throwing out the kool-aid shamswill. Rob B June 19, 2017 $500 out of nothing. I will agree with that part. You also posted the following: “I apologize for my initial post, just wanted an opinion on the possiblity legit room. I’ll likely never do it and just keep trading my own acct. My last post here, but I’ll keep reading.” So you lied about that being your last post and now just posting fictitious trade call results. Maybe you can make some youtube videos of you opening your account each day and showing those amazing results and post that link here. So far anything related regarding you and actual proof has mysteriously disappeared into the wind. Emmett Moore June 19, 2017 Tough crowd. James II June 19, 2017 I’ll post 3 ES trades here tomorrow that will make me 500 before noon, thats better any Utube! Rob B June 19, 2017 Sure, Post those 3 trades with entries, stop loss and profit target prior to them being taken so we see the time and can then see exactly what they did. In fact include an ES chart right before the trade with time stamps which will match to the post time shown here. Otherwise the post would be completely meaningless. Day Trading one of the few corrupt industries were demanding folks show proof of their claims is considered a tough crowd. BTW the youtube videos was too show proof of your claims. But being you started as James and then replied to your own post as James, but yet claimed to be another James and the posted as James II and then again as JamesII (no space) and talked about opening a trading room, yes call me skeptical. James II June 20, 2017 Rob, I’m not going to do it. (I could but I’m not). You got me a little annoyed thats when I spouted off about demonstrating here with 3 trades. I don’t want to trash Emmetts sight with superfluous BS. All a good trader needs is PRICE MOVEMENT. Up, down sideways doesn’t matter when on right side. BTW, I switched up to James II because I didn’t realize Emmett already had a “James” here. Peace Out. Rob B June 20, 2017 “Rob, I’m not going to do it. (I could but I’m not). ” WOW, what a shocker!! I am so disappointed. Here is the facts, we were not going to stand by and have you post a bunch of fake hindsight called trades and the 2nd anyone called you out and demand you post them ahead of time with proof, you disappear. If you were legit you would have step up to the challenge and I would think be excited to prove you are real deal. So I guess you will have to go somewhere else to promote you up and coming TR that will never show any proof of anything. You are nothing but another BS scammer and I doubt you could trade your way out of a paper bag. I dare you to prove me wrong. And no I am not proud of you! James II June 20, 2017 Rob, I’m not going to start slinging trades calls all over the internet, every trade has a context if someone were to lose $ I’d feel bad about that. Besides, you guys agree that takes months of trades to show a statistical result. I was mad why i threw that out. Pointless, and why I won’t do it. I doubt I’ll ever do a room but came here asking because you guys know a lot about it. How it shouldn’t be done. Rob B June 20, 2017 “Pointless, and why I won’t do it.” Well we do agree on that. I have no idea what your real intentions are, but I know we have had plenty of scammer come here and this entire industry is nothing but scammers. You came here talking about opening a TR and then talked about posting trades, yet never answer any hard questions or were your willing to show any proof of your claims. That speaks volumes to me. Maybe you think you can day trade ES profitably. Who know. Believe and doing it is not the same and unless you show some actual proof it is just for Entertainment purposes only. If that is your goal go to stocktwits and post your trades and links to your future TR. But if you are serious, then first you need to show some proof of your claims. You can start by showing Emmett your live brokerage statements showing you have been scalping the ES profitable for months. If you cannot do that or address that then your claims of successfully daytrading are meaningless!!!!! And if you do not get that then I can not help you, maybe someone else can. But based on your past posts where you just ignore any demand to any show proof of your claims, I don’t need a crystal ball to predict the future. But I cannot help but wonder is there anyone dumb enough to take your word and pay you $299 for that TR. Sadly probably so. JamesII June 20, 2017 You claim 20% yearly I assume on huge coin? where your proof???? dtchurn June 19, 2017 “I’ll post 3 ES trades here tomorrow that will make me 500 before noon,”. Very newbish wannabe scam vendor statement. Most seasoned shamsters usually say they already made x $ thousands “recently”, or “last month”. But here, it’s unbelievable prognosticating the future like a palm reader. Or , with that level of confidence of trading, you would be trading at a hedge fund for millionaires already. I was fooled initially, but now I wonder if James = James II = Pete all along. Only he would come up with trollish bs from a hole in the cave about “starting daytrading” on thinkorswim years ago when TOS was mainly for the monthly commission churn of “monthly income” “trading spreads for a living” in an attempt to undermine other posters out of the usual deranged forum b__ks diseased spite. Rob B June 19, 2017 Indeed, James II knows by noon tomorrow he will make $500 in ES no matter what. The market can be up, down or sideways, but no matter what he is guarantying $500 in profits from trading ES. He would be the most sought after trader ever. These leads me to one of 2 conclusion, his posts are some kind or sarcasm and a complete joke or he is seriously mentally disturbed. Maybe someone else can explain which of the 2 it is. James II June 19, 2017 I said all that because I thought Emmett was mad at me and I was being censored …so I was just going to bow out. Turned out my posts weren’t being censored just under moderation i guess. I doubt i’ll post much more …Emmett should i get out of line please let me know. Mike M June 20, 2017 One must be prepared to back up any and all claims of profitability. Rob B, not too harsh, exactly what I would expect from the loyal readers of this site. I am thoroughly entertained, but I stand by my statement that your diligence must be commended. I don’t know where you can get the energy to volley with the TR operators or whatever we are calling them now. Honestly, I enjoy these posts and look forward to them every single day, but I think we have to be careful if someone may just be trolling. Reply Rob B June 20, 2017 Mike, I wish I could argue with some rational person like you instead. But yes indeed even I will stop replying when it get too ridiculous like with Pete. After the latest nonsense post from James I am about at that point. No one can be that mentally ill to post his nonsense unless it is on purpose just to piss me off. So I must breath-in and say ummmmmm and let it go. JamesII June 20, 2017 i just took an ES short Reply Rob B June 20, 2017 WTF is wrong with you. What happened to: “Rob, I’m not going to start slinging trades calls all over the internet, ….. I was mad why i threw that out. Pointless, and why I won’t do it.” And now you post meaningless BS calls. Really you shorted with no details so no matter what the market does you can call your trade a winner. This is complete nonsense. And people think I am too harsh. You cannot be harsh enough on a fool like this. Go get help. YOU NEED IT!!!!!!! In fact it is so obvious at this point you have serious mental issues with your nonsense post, I will try not to even respond to your silly post unless it is just too over the top or personal mentions me. Someone else can deal with your insanity. Maybe I will just replay, “Another BS post brought to you by James”. Reply JamesII June 20, 2017 I’m a trader, if thats wrong then so be it i love it Reply Rob B June 20, 2017 What wrong is your constant lies and BS posting. You plan to post here every time you now make a fantasy trade after you stated you would not. You really thinking posting, “i just took an ES short” means anything. Gee I am wasting my time as there is clearly somethng seriously wrong with you. I seriously doubt you have ever taken a live trade. « Older Comments Newer Comments » Leave a Reply Cancel reply Name* Email* Website Comment*Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Yes, add me to your mailing list This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.